The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by the President on Immigration Reform -- San Francisco, CA

Betty Ong Chinese Recreation Center
San Francisco, California

11:55 A.M. PST

THE PRESIDENT:  Hello, everybody!  (Applause.)  Well, hello, San Francisco!  (Applause.)  It is great to be back in California.  It is great to be with all of you.  I love San Francisco.  (Applause.)  You got great food.  You got great people, beautiful scenery -- no more super villains because Batkid cleaned up the streets.  (Applause.)  Love Batkid.  (Laughter.)   

I want to start by thanking Geetha for the wonderful  introduction and the great work that she’s doing.  Give her a big round of applause.  (Applause.)  I want to thank your Mayor, Ed Lee.  (Applause.)  Lieutenant Governor Gavin Newsom.  (Applause.)  I want to recognize some wonderful members of Congress who are fighting every day for the people of California -- Mike Honda -- (applause) -- Eric Swalwell, Judy Chu.  They are all doing great work every single day.  (Applause.)

We have a special guest, Janet Napolitano, who is now overseeing the entire UC system and going to be doing a great job.  (Applause.)  We miss her back in Washington, but she is going to be outstanding leading the University of California.

Now, before I begin, I want to say a few words about the news from the weekend.  I'm here to talk about immigration reform, but I'm also here in my capacity as Commander-in-Chief, and this weekend, together with our allies and our partners, the United States reached an agreement with Iran -- (applause) -- on a first step towards resolving our concerns over its nuclear program. 

Now, some of you may recall that when I first ran for President, I said it was time for a new era of American leadership in the world -- one that turned the page on a decade of war, and began a new era of our engagement with the world.  And as President and as Commander-in-Chief, I’ve done what I said.  We ended the war in Iraq; we brought our troops home.  Osama bin Laden met justice; the war in Afghanistan will end next year. 

And as the strongest, most powerful nation on the face of the Earth, we’ve engaged in clear-eyed and principled diplomacy  -- even with our adversaries -- in order to begin to destroy Syria’s chemical weapons and to place the first real constraints in a decade on Iran’s nuclear program.  Because I firmly believe in what President Kennedy once said:  He said, “Let us never negotiate out of fear, but let us never fear to negotiate.”  I believe that.  And this diplomacy, backed by the unprecedented sanctions we brought on Iran, has brought us the progress that was achieved this weekend. 

For the first time in a decade, we’ve halted the progress on Iran’s nuclear program.  Key parts of the program will be rolled back.  (Applause.)  International inspectors will have unprecedented access to Iran’s nuclear-related facilities.  So this will help Iran from building a nuclear weapon.  And over the coming months, we’re going to continue our diplomacy, with the goal of achieving a comprehensive solution that deals with the threat of Iran’s nuclear program once and for all. 

And if Iran seizes this opportunity and chooses to join the global community, then we can begin to chip away at the mistrust that’s existed for many, many years between our two nations.
 
None of that is going to be easy.  Huge challenges remain.  But we cannot close the door on diplomacy.  And we cannot rule out peaceful solutions to the world’s problems.  We cannot commit ourselves to an endless cycle of conflict.  And tough talk and bluster may be the easy thing to do politically, but it’s not the right thing for our security.  It is not the right thing for our security.  (Applause.) 

Now, this progress, and the potential it offers, reminds us of what is possible when the United States has the courage to lead -- not just with the force of arms, but with the strength of our diplomacy and our commitment to peace.  That’s what keeps us strong.  That’s what makes us a beacon to the world.  That’s how I’ll continue to lead so long as I’m President of the United States.

And that spirit -- not just what we can criticize or tear down or be against, but what we can build together -- that’s what brings me here today.  Because it’s long past time to fix our broken immigration system.  (Applause.)  We need to make sure Washington finishes what so many Americans just like you started. We’ve got to finish the job.

And it’s fitting that we’re here in Chinatown, just a few miles away from Angel Island.  In the early 1900s, about 300,000 people -- maybe some of your ancestors -- passed through on their way to a new life in America.  And for many, it represented the end of a long and arduous journey -- they’d finally arrived in a place where they believed anything was possible.

And for some, it also represented the beginning of a new struggle against prejudice in a country that didn’t always treat its immigrants fairly or afford them the same rights as everybody else.  Obviously, Asians faced this, but so did the Irish; so did Italians; so did Jews; and many groups still do today.

That didn’t stop those brave men and women from coming.  They were drawn by a belief in the power of opportunity; in a belief that says, maybe I never had a chance at a good education, but this is a place where my daughter can go to college.  Maybe I started out washing dishes, but this is a place where my son can become mayor of San Francisco.  (Applause.)  Maybe I have to make sacrifices today, but those sacrifices are worth it if it means a better life for my family.

And that’s a family story that will be shared by millions of Americans around the table on Thursday.  It’s the story that drew my great-great-great-great-grandfather from a small village in Ireland, and drew my father from a small village in Kenya.  It’s the story that drew so many of your ancestors here -- that America is a place where you can make it if you try.

And here’s something interesting:  Today, more than one in four residents born outside the United States came here from Asian countries -- many through our family immigration system.  They’re doctors and business owners, laborers, refugees.  This rec center’s namesake, Betty Ong, was a hero on 9/11.  (Applause.)  But she was also the daughter of immigrants who grew up not far from here.  And we’re honored to have her family with us here today.  (Applause.)

But too often when we talk about immigration, the debate focuses on our southern border.  The fact is we’re blessed with immigrants from all over the world who’ve put down roots in every corner of this country.  Here in San Francisco, 35 percent of business owners are immigrants -- and your economy is among the fastest growing in the country.  That’s not an accident.  That’s the impact that our talented, hardworking immigrants can have.  That’s the difference they can make.  They’re hungry and they’re striving and they’re working hard and they’re creating things that weren’t there before. 

And that’s why it is long past time to reform an immigration system that right now doesn’t serve America as well as it should. We could be doing so much more to unleash our potential if we just fix this aspect of our system. 

And I know out here in California that you watch the news and you share the country’s not very sunny view of Washington these days.  For the last few months, you’ve seen a lot of headlines about gridlock and partisan bickering, and too often one faction of one party in one house of Congress has chosen courses of action that ended up harming our businesses, or our economy, or our workers.  Or they want to refight old political battles rather than create jobs and grow the economy and strengthen the middle class, or take 40 more votes to undermine or repeal the Affordable Care Act -- (laughter) -- instead of passing a single serious jobs bill, despite the fact that Americans want us to focus on jobs and business and growth.  And, by the way, thousands of Californians are signing up every day for new health care plans all across this state.  (Applause.)  

So even as we’re getting this darn website up to speed -- (laughter) -- and it's getting better -- states like California are proving the law works.  People want the financial security of health insurance.

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  Thanks to you!

THE PRESIDENT:  And even if you’re already insured, reach out to a friend or neighbor who’s not and help them get covered.

But when it comes to immigration reform, we have to have the confidence to believe we can get this done.  And we should get it done.  And, by the way, most Americans agree.  The only thing standing in our way right now is the unwillingness of certain Republicans in Congress to catch up with the rest of the country. 
I met the other day with the CEOs of some of America's biggest companies.  And I'm positive not all of them voted for me.  (Laughter.)  I'm pretty sure.  (Laughter.)  Maybe some of them, but definitely not all of them.  But the thing they wanted to talk about, their top priority was the fact that we invite the brightest minds from around the world to study here -- many of them enrolled in the University of California system -- and then we don't invite them to stay.  We end up sending them home to create new jobs and start new businesses someplace else.  So we're training our own competition, rather than invite those incredibly talented young people, like Geetha, to stay here and start businesses and create jobs here. 

I hear from folks who’ve been separated from their families for years because of green card backlogs who desperately want their loved ones to be able to join them here in America.  I hear from young DREAMers who are Americans through and through in every way but on paper, and they just want a chance to study and serve and contribute to the nation that they love.  (Applause.) 

I talk to business owners who play by the rules, but get frustrated because they end up being undercut by those who exploit workers in a shadow economy -- aren't getting paid overtime, aren't required to meet the same obligations.  And so those companies end up losing out on business.

Right now, I'm seeing brave advocates who have been fasting for two weeks in the shadow of the Capitol, sacrificing themselves in an effort to get Congress to act.  And I want to say to Eliseo Medina, my friend from SEIU, and the other fasters who are there as we speak, I want them to know we hear you.  We're with you.  The whole country hears you. 

And there are plenty of leaders –- Democrat and Republican  –- who don’t think it’s fair that we’ve got 11 million people in this country, including more than a million from Asia, with no real way to come forward and get on the right side of the law.  It’s not smart.  It’s not fair.  It doesn’t make sense.  And we have kicked this particular can down the road long enough.  Everybody knows it.

Now, the good news is we know what the solutions are.  There is bipartisan hope of getting it done.  This year, the Senate passed an immigration reform bill by a wide, bipartisan majority, and it addresses the key issues that need to be addressed.  It would strengthen our borders.  It would level the playing field by holding employers accountable if they knowingly hire undocumented workers.  It would modernize our legal immigration system so that we eliminate the backlog of family visas and make it easier to attract highly skilled entrepreneurs from beyond our borders.  It would make sure that everybody plays by the same rules by providing a pathway to earned citizenship for those who are living in the shadows –- a path that includes passing a background check, and learning English, and paying taxes and a penalty, and getting in line behind everyone trying to come here the right way. 

And each of these pieces would go a long way towards fixing our broken immigration system.  Each of them has been supported by Democrats and Republicans in the past.  There’s no reason we can’t come together and get it done.

And what's more, we know the immigration reform that we're proposing would boost our economy and shrink our deficits.  Independent economists have said that if the Senate bill became law, over the next two decades, our economy would grow by $1.4 trillion more, and it would reduce our deficits by $850 billion more. 

And you don’t have to be an economist to figure out that workers will be more productive if they’ve got their families here with them, they're not worried about deportation, they're not living halfway around the world.  This isn’t just the right thing to do -– it’s the smart thing to do.

Of course, just because something is smart, fair, good for the economy, and supported by business, labor, law enforcement and faith leaders -- (laughter) -- Democratic and Republican governors, including the Governor of this state –- just because all that is in place doesn’t mean we'll actually get it done, because this is Washington, after all, that we’re talking about and everything is looked through a political prism.  And, look, let's be honest, some folks automatically think, well, if Obama’s for it, then I've got to be against it even if I was, before that, I was for it.

But I want to remind everybody, to his great credit, my Republican predecessor, President Bush, was for reform.  He proposed reform like this almost a decade ago.  I was in the Senate.  I joined 23 Senate Republicans back then supporting reform.  It's worth remembering that the Senate bill that just passed won more than a dozen Republican votes this past summer.  And some of them even forget that I'm -- sometimes people forget I'm not running for office again.  Michelle doesn’t forget.   (Laughter and applause.)  So you don’t have to worry about this somehow being good for me.  This is good for the country.   It's the right thing to do for the American people. 

And I believe, ultimately -- not always in the short term -- but ultimately, good policy is good politics.  Look at the polls right now, because the American people support immigration reform by a clear majority.  Everybody wins if we get this done.  So there's no reason we shouldn’t get immigration reform done right now.  None.  If there is a good reason I haven't heard it.

And, by the way, if there's a better plan out there than the one that Democrats and Republicans have already advanced together, if there are additional ideas that would make it even better, I’m always willing to listen to new ideas.  My door is always open.  But right now it’s up to Republicans in the House to decide if we can move forward as a country on this bill.  If they don’t want to see it happen, they’ve got to explain why.

The good news is, just this past week Speaker Boehner said that he is “hopeful we can make progress” on immigration reform. And that is good news.  I believe the Speaker is sincere.  I think he genuinely wants to get it done.  And that’s something we should be thankful for this week.  And I think there are a number of other House Republicans who also want to get this done.  Some of them are hesitant to do it in one big bill, like the Senate did.  That’s okay.  They can -- it’s Thanksgiving; we can carve that bird into multiple pieces.  (Laughter.)  A drumstick here -- (laughter) -- breast meat there.  But as long as all the pieces get done -- soon -- and we actually deliver on the core values we’ve been talking about for so long, I think everybody is fine with it.  They're not worried about the procedures.  They just want the result.

But it’s going to require some courage.  There are some members of the Republican caucus who think this is bad politics for them back home.  And they're free to vote their conscience, but what I’ve said to the Speaker and others is, don't let a minority of folks block something that the country desperately needs.  And we can’t leave this problem for another generation to solve.  If we don’t tackle this now, then we’re undercutting our own future. 

So my message to Congress is rather than create problems, let’s prove Washington can get something done.  This is something that has broad-based support.  We’ve been working on it for a decade now.  This reform comes as close as we’ve gotten to something that will benefit everybody, now and for decades to come.  And it has the potential to enrich this country in ways that we can’t even imagine.

And I’ll just give you one example to wrap up.  Andrew Ly is here today.  Where’s Andrew?  He’s around here somewhere.  There he is.  Now, Andrew has got an amazing story.  Andrew grew up in Vietnam, and he and his four brothers tried three times to flee to the United States.  Obviously, the country was going through all kinds of difficulties.  So three times, they tried; three times, they failed.  On the fourth try, their boat –- filled with 140 refugees -- is that right, Andrew -– was attacked by pirates.

But the Lys and their family eventually made it to Malaysia, and then they eventually made it here to San Francisco.  And they learned English, and they worked as handymen, and they worked as seamstresses.  And eventually, Andrew and his brothers earned enough money to buy a small bakery.  And they started making donuts, and they started selling them to Chinese restaurants.  And with a lot of hard work and a little luck, the Sugar Bowl Bakery today is a $60 million business.  (Applause.) 

So these humble and striving immigrants from Vietnam now employ more than 300 Americans.  They’re supplying pastries to Costco and Safeway, and almost every hotel and hospital in San Francisco.  And I don't know if Andrew brought me any samples, but -- (laughter) -- they must be pretty good.  (Laughter.)   

And Andrew says, “We came here as boat people, so we don’t take things for granted.  We know this is the best country in the world if you work hard.”  That’s what America is about.  This is the place where you can reach for something better if you work hard.  This is the country our parents and our grandparents and waves of immigrants before them built for us.  And it falls on each new generation to keep it that way.  The Statue of Liberty doesn’t have its back to the world.  The Statue of Liberty faces the world and raises its light to the world. 

When Chinese immigrants came to this city in search of “Gold Mountain,” they weren’t looking just for physical riches.  They were looking for freedom and opportunity.  They knew that what makes us American is not a question of what we look like or what our names are -- because we look like the world.  You got a President named Obama.  (Laughter and applause.)  What makes us American is our shared belief in certain enduring principles, our allegiance to a set of ideals, to a creed, to the enduring promise of this country. 

And our shared responsibility is to leave this country more generous, more hopeful than we found it.  And if we stay true to that history -- if we get immigration reform across the finish line -- and it is there just within our grasp, if we can just get folks in Washington to go ahead and do what needs to be done -- we’re going to grow our economy; we’re going to make our country more secure; we’ll strengthen our families; and most importantly, we will live --

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  Mr. Obama --

THE PRESIDENT:  -- most importantly, we will live up --

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  -- my family has been separated for 19 months now --

THE PRESIDENT:  -- most importantly, we will live up to our character as a nation.

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  I’ve not seen my family.  Our families are separated.  I need your help.  There are thousands of people --

THE PRESDIENT:  That’s exactly what we’re talking about.

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  -- are torn apart every single day. 

THE PRESIDENT:  That’s why we’re here.

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  Mr. President, please use your executive order to halt deportations for all 11.5 undocumented immigrants in this country right now. 

THE PRESIDENT:  What we’re trying --

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  Do you agree

AUDIENCE:  Obama!  Obama!  Obama!

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  -- that we need to pass comprehensive immigration reform at the same time we -- you have a power to stop deportation for all undocumented immigrants in this country. 
THE PRESIDENT:  Actually I don’t.  And that’s why we’re here.

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  So, please, I need your help. 

THE PRESIDENT:  Okay -- 

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  Stop deportations! 

AUDIENCE MEMBER:  Stop deportations! 

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you.  All right. 

AUDIENCE MEMBERS:  Stop deportations!  Stop deportations!

THE PRESIDENT:  What I’d like to do -- no, no, don’t worry about it, guys.  Okay, let me finish. 

AUDIENCE MEMBERS:  Stop deportations!  Yes, we can!  Stop deportations!

THE PRESIDENT:  These guys don’t need to go.  Let me finish. No, no, no, he can stay there.  Hold on a second.  (Applause.)  Hold on a second. 

So I respect the passion of these young people because they feel deeply about the concerns for their families.  Now, what you need to know, when I’m speaking as President of the United States and I come to this community, is that if, in fact, I could solve all these problems without passing laws in Congress, then I would do so. 

But we’re also a nation of laws.  That’s part of our tradition.  And so the easy way out is to try to yell and pretend like I can do something by violating our laws.  And what I’m proposing is the harder path, which is to use our democratic processes to achieve the same goal that you want to achieve.  But it won’t be as easy as just shouting.  It requires us lobbying and getting it done.  (Applause.)

So for those of you who are committed to getting this done, I am going to march with you and fight with you every step of the way to make sure that we are welcoming every striving, hardworking immigrant who sees America the same way we do -- as a country where no matter who you are or what you look like or where you come from, you can make it if you try. 

And if you’re serious about making that happen, then I’m ready to work with you.  (Applause.)  But it is going to require work.  It is not simply a matter of us just saying we’re going to violate the law.  That’s not our tradition.  The great thing about this country is we have this wonderful process of democracy, and sometimes it is messy, and sometimes it is hard, but ultimately, justice and truth win out.  That’s always been the case in this country; that’s going to continue to be the case today.  (Applause.)

Thank you very much, everybody.  God bless you.  God bless America.  (Applause.)

END
12:24 P.M. PST

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by the President at DCCC Event -- Seattle, WA

Private Residence
Seattle, Washington  
 
 
7:24 P.M. PST
 
THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you!  Thank you, guys.  (Applause.)  Sit down.  You already did that.  Thank you.  Thank you, everybody.  Have a seat.  Have a seat.  
 
Well, first of all, let me just thank Jon for the second time for his incredible hospitality.  And I think it’s fair to say that between Nancy and me and Steve Israel, we do a lot of events.  I will say that this particular space is one of the more spectacular venues for an event.  (Applause.)  And we couldn’t have a more gracious host.  The only problem when I come to Jon’s house is I want to just kind of roam around and check stuff out, and instead I’ve got to talk.  (Laughter.)  But Jon, thank you for your friendship. We’ve very grateful.
 
A few other people I want to acknowledge.  First of all, our once Speaker and soon to be Speaker again, Nancy Pelosi.  We are thrilled to be with her.  (Applause.)  Someone who has an incredibly thankless job, but does it with energy and wisdom -- and I was going to say joy, but I’m not, I don’t want to kind of overdo it -- (laughter) -- but is doing an outstanding job -- Steve Israel, who is heading up the DCCC.  Thank you so much, Steve, for the great job that you’re doing.  (Applause.)  
 
We’ve got some outstanding members of Congress here.  Congressman Rick Larsen is here.  Where’s Rick?  There he is.(Applause.)  Congresswoman Suzan DelBene is here.  (Applause.)  Congressman Derek Kilmer is here.  Where’s Derek? There he is -- (applause) -- who just informed me that his four-year-old at the Christmas party is going to sing me at least one patriotic song. (Laughter.)  And I’m very excited about this.  She has a repertoire of five songs, and we’re trying to hone in on what one song she is going to do.  
 
And you’ve got a former outstanding member of Congress, who now is doing a great job as the Governor of this great state -- Governor Jay Inslee is here.  (Applause.)  And Trudi, who’s keeping him in line at all times.  (Applause.)  And I want to thank John Frank, who also spent a lot of time on this event.  Thank you so much.  (Applause.)
 
Now, the great thing about these kinds of events is I spend most of my time in a conversation with you, as opposed to just making a long speech.  Let me make a couple of observations.  Number one, Jay claims he arranged it, but when we landed, we were flying over Mt. Rainier -- pulled into the airport, came off the plane, and the sunset was lighting the mountain.  And it was spectacular, and reminded me of why it is that I love the Pacific Northwest so much.  
 
Now, part of it -- I was saying to somebody, part of it may also be that I always feel the spirit of my mom here, because I graduated from Mercer Island High.  (Applause.)  But you guys have got a good thing going here, and it’s not just the Seahawks. I just want to make that point.  (Applause.)  
 
Point number two, obviously, there are such enormous challenges that we face all across this country and internationally, and this year we’ve seen issues ranging from the tragedy of Sandy Hook to disclosures at the NSA to the shutdown and the potential of default to continuing issues surrounding the Middle East and peace there.  And so it’s understandable, I think, that sometimes people feel discouraged or concerned about whether or not we can continue to make progress.  And one thing that I always try to emphasize is that if you look at American history, there have been frequent occasions in which it looked like we had insoluble problems -- either economic, political, security -- and as long as there were those who stayed steady and clear-eyed and persistent, eventually we came up with an answer; eventually we were able to work through these challenges and come out better on the other end.  
 
And that’s true today as well.  After seeing the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, we’ve now seen 44 straight months of job growth.  We’ve doubled our production of clean energy.  We are actually importing less oil than ever before, producing more energy than ever before.  We’ve reduced the pace of our carbon emissions in a way that is actually better than the vast majority of industrialized nations over the last five years.  
 
We’ve been able to not only create the possibility of all people enjoying the security of health care, but we’ve also been driving down the cost of health care, which benefits people’s pocket books, their businesses.  Our institutions of higher learning continue to be the best in the world.  And you’re actually -- because of the productivity of our workers, we’re actually seeing manufacturing move back to America in ways that we haven’t seen in decades.
 
 A lot of the reason that we’re making progress is because of the inherent resilience and strength of the American people, but a lot of it is because folks like Nancy Pelosi and some of the members of Congress, or even former members of Congress who are here made some tough decisions early on in my administration.  And we’re starting to see those bear fruit and pay off.  
 
And so I’m incredibly optimistic about our future.  But I’m also mindful of the fact that we have some barriers, some impediments to change and progress.  And the biggest barrier and impediment we have right now is a Congress -- and in particular, a House of Representatives -- that is not focused on getting the job done for the American people, but is a lot more focused on trying to position themselves for the next election or to defeat my agenda.  
 
 And that’s unfortunate, because that’s not what the American people are looking for right now.  And the truth is, is that there are a lot of ideas -- things like early childhood education, or rebuilding our infrastructure, or investing in basic science and research -- there are a whole range of -- immigration reform -- a whole range of ideas that if you strip away the politics, there’s actually a pretty broad consensus in this country.  
 
I’m not a particularly ideological person.  There are some things, some values I feel passionately about.  I feel passionate about making sure everybody in this country gets a fair shake.  I feel passionate about everybody being treated with dignity and respect regardless of what they look like or what their last name is or who they love.  I feel passionate about making sure that we’re leaving a planet that is as spectacular as the one we inherited from our parents and our grandparents.  I feel passionate about working for peace even as we are making sure that our defenses are strong.
 
So there are values I care about.  But I’m pretty pragmatic when it comes to how do we get there -- and so is Nancy, and so is Jay.  And so more than anything, what we’re looking for is not the defeat of another party; what we’re looking for is the advancement of ideas that are going to vindicate those values that are tried and true, and that have led this country to the spectacular heights that we’ve seen in the past.
 
 But to do that we’re going to need Nancy Pelosi as Speaker, because there’s just a lot of work to be done right now.  Between now and next November, I’m going to do everything I can and look for every opportunity to work on a bipartisan basis to get stuff done.  There will not be a point in time where I’ve got an opportunity to get something done where I don't do it simply because of politics.  But those opportunity have been few and far between over the last several years, and the American people can’t afford to wait in perpetuity for us to grow faster, create more jobs, strengthen our middle class, clean our environment, fix our immigration system.
 
And so if we don't have partners on the other side, we’re going to have to go ahead and do it ourselves.  And so the support that you’re providing today and the support that you’ve provided time and again is making all the difference in the world.  And it’s part of what gives me confidence that we’re going to be successful over the long term.  
 
So thank you.  We appreciate it.  
 
And with that, let me take some questions.  (Applause.) 
 
END          
7:35 P.M. PST
 

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by the First Lady at National Arts and Humanities Youth Program Awards

East Room
 
 
2:24 P.M. EST
 
MRS. OBAMA:  Well, hello, everyone.  (Applause.)    
 
AUDIENCE:  Hello.
 
MRS. OBAMA:  Welcome to the White House -- again!  (Laughter.)  This is a good time.  We are excited to have you all here.  It’s a pleasure to be here today for the National Arts and Humanities Youth Program Awards, where we honor outstanding organizations that are using the arts to lift up our young people.  
 
And I want to start by thanking everyone from the President’s Committee on the Arts and Humanities for sponsoring these awards.  And we just announced seven tremendous new committee members this week, and we’re very excited about that.  But I’d like to take a moment to ask everyone from the committee who is here to please stand so that we can recognize you for your amazing work.  (Applause.)  Thank you all so much.
 
As I told them backstage, this is a real, working committee.  And I just want to tell you how proud I have been to work beside you all.  You all do real roll-up-your-sleeves kind of work, and it really matters, not just to me and to the President but to the lives of so many young people.  You all should be so proud of yourselves.  We are absolutely proud and grateful.  So thank you.
 
I also want to recognize Representatives Elijah Cummings and Bobby Scott.  Where are -- hello.  How are you?  (Applause.)  We also have Ambassador Kamau, who’s here.  Ambassador, thank you.  It’s wonderful to have you here.  (Applause.)  And of course, we have to recognize all of our young folks, the young people who are here today.  (Applause.)  We’re so proud.  You guys are so special.  I hope -- do you feel special right about now?  You should.  (Laughter.)  That’s good.  That’s the point.  We want you to feel special.  (Laughter.)
 
I also want to draw your attention to this beautiful pastel painting here on stage, which was made by our student speaker, Danashiya Pritchard -- Danashiya? -- who we are going to hear from.  You don’t have to come up yet.  She’s like, “Oh, my God, not now!”  (Laughter.)  She’s going to come up and tell us a little bit about herself and her work.  We are so proud of you, sweetie.  Don’t be nervous.  (Laughter.)  None of these people bite.  
 
And of course, I want to thank all of the artists, the teachers, the administrators in the audience who do the real work.  You guys are amazing.  Every day, you are out there pouring your heart and soul into these programs.  You’ve taking time out of your own lives to give young people the guidance and the support they need to be their very best.  You’re doing whatever it takes.  Many of you are answering phone calls and emails late into the night; you’re reaching into your own pockets when necessary.  And you’re doing this because you know the difference that the arts can make in young people’s lives.  You know this better than anyone.
 
You see firsthand that giving a child the chance to fill a canvas, or to perfect a harmony, or to shine on stage, that can stoke the flames of a lifelong passion, and it can teach valuable skills -- skills like hard work and persistence.  I could go on and on.  You know the skills.  It can open up possibilities that young people might not otherwise see for themselves.  And there are thousands of programs all across this country that are doing this kind of important work every day.  And today’s honorees represent organizations that have found new and creative ways to give young people these opportunities.  
 
For example, in Baltimore, the Baltimore Symphony Orchestra is providing instruments, mentors, and classes to help young people experience the magic of music and the magic of the orchestra at a very early age.  In Chicago, my hometown -- (laughter) -- StoryCatchers Theatre is helping underserved young people and those in the juvenile justice system write, produce, and perform their own musicals based on their own personal stories.  In Los Angeles, WriteGirl is matching at-risk young women with professional writers for one-on-one mentoring and coaching.  And these girls are learning to express themselves through poetry, and journaling, and investigative writing.  And in the last dozen years through this program, every single one of the program’s graduating seniors has gone on to college.
 
And these are just a few examples of how all of you are using the power of the arts to change our young people’s lives.  And as First Lady, as you know, that is something that I’ve been working hard to do as well every day in the White House.  With the incredible support of this phenomenal committee, we’ve been able to host youth workshops on everything from country music to modern dance to poetry.  In fact, just a few weeks ago, we put together one of our best events ever -- something we called our “Careers in Film Symposium.”  We had some of the biggest and best in Hollywood come, where we brought together about 80 students from Boston, New York and Washington.  All of these were young people enrolled in arts and film programs that we were talking about, and they were there to help celebrate the day.  
 
And we did everything right here on the State Floor.  We set up in the Green Room a green screen so that the kids could learn about special effects.  We brought in award-winning directors who worked one on one with these kids to teach them how to bring out the best in their colleagues and in each other.  In the Blue Room, we let them play around with some makeup, which terrified our curator.  (Laughter.)  But they were able to practice that special-effects makeup, and they put on some disturbingly lifelike cuts and bruises on our staff members -- (laughter) -- who then walked around all day looking like -- with vampire bites.  (Laughter.)  And many of them forgot they had these on, and they were in the West Wing.  And I think one of them passed by Denis McDonough, who sort of looked in horror.  (Laughter.)  But it was a lot of fun.
 
And as I walked around and talked to these young people, and I saw the looks in their eyes, I could tell that they were beginning to truly understand -- some of them maybe for the first time -- that they really do have what it takes to make it in the movie business or anywhere else for that matter; they started to envision possibilities for themselves that they never even imagined just from that day.  
 
I spoke to one young man who told me that he had never thought of pursuing special effects until that day.  And he was one of the kids -- I think he spent all of his time putting on that makeup.  (Laughter.)  But he was just drawn to it in a way that it surprised him.  And we heard later from the teachers and coaches who told us that their students left with a purpose and a fire they’d never seen before.
    
So that’s what the arts can do, a little exposure.  And the research shows that what those kids learned on that day won’t just further their interest in the arts; as you all know, it furthers their academic performance, as well.  You all know this.  Studies have shown that students who are highly involved in the arts stay in school longer than those who are less involved.  Arts education also leads to better scores in reading and math.  And it makes students much more motivated and engaged, period, in school.  They come to school more, they set higher goals for themselves, and they have a reason to achieve them because they’re determined to succeed because they’re passionate about something.  
 
And those are just some of the skills -- those skills, skills like grit and determination and resilience that they learn from this work.  Those skills will lead students to success no matter what path they choose.  You all know this.  You experience this every day.  And as you might have heard, I believe in this as well myself.  
 
I’m going to be spending a lot more of my time trying to inspire students in this country to use those skills to complete their education, talk to them more about the importance of reaching beyond high school, and the power that they already have to make that happen.  So I hope to join you in those efforts, and make that a big part of what I do for the time that I’m here.  We know that arts education and programs like yours can play an important role in achieving the President’s North Star goal, which is one of the reasons why we are so passionately supporting you all.
 
So I simply want to say thank you to all of you for the critical work that you’re doing every day.  Thank you for laying that foundation for so many kids.  I met with our performers today, all of them so bright and articulate and confident, looking me in the eye, introducing themselves.  (Laughter.)  Only arts can do that.  (Laughter.)  Yes, indeed.  (Applause)  
 
And to all the young people who are here today, I just want to say this:  I know you all probably already know this, but just in case you don’t, these programs will and are changing your lives.  So stick with it.  Stick with it.  If you love what you’re doing, immerse yourself in it.  Find the thing you’re passionate about and dig really deep.  Don’t be afraid to fail.  Just dig deep.  Give it all you’ve got, whether it’s writing or design or music.  Whatever it is, hold onto it.
 
Because no matter whether you ultimately want to go into the arts, or whether you ultimately want to go into business or teaching, whatever it is, the skills that you are learning in these programs will help you do whatever it is you can imagine for yourselves.  But as I always say, you’ve got to work hard.  That is really the message.  None of this stuff comes easy.  You have to be willing to put in the work.  Just like you do in the things that you’re passionate about, you have to bring that kind of energy to every single thing you do.  That means you’ve got to get up and go to school every day -- no exceptions.  You’ve got to finish school.  High school is not your starting point.  It is not your end.  It is the beginning.  Completing high school is the beginning of a lifelong dream of education that I hope you guys pursue.
 
And we all have your back.  We do.  You’ve got a President who is working hard to make sure you have the resources you need. You have teachers.  You’ve got parents.  You’ve got this committee of people.  They’re really important.  (Laughter.)  They are.
Just look at them.  It’s like, these are some pretty impressive people.  They care so much about you guys.  
 
So we are investing in you, so keep investing in yourself.  You promise me that.  Promise?  All right.  (Laughter.)  You’ve got what it takes.  Set your bar high, okay?  Set it really high.  Don’t let anybody talk you down to a lower bar.  Think big.  Think about being here one day, running it, all right?  (Laughter and applause.)  And if you guys do that, you can do whatever you want in life.  You got that? 
 
So with that, I’m going to turn it over to the co-chair of the President’s Committee on the Arts and the Humanities, my dear friend, Margo Lion.  Thank you, Margo.  (Applause.)
 
END
2:37 P.M. EST
 
 

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Weekly Address: Working with Both Parties to Keep the Economy Moving Forward

WASHINGTON, DC— In his weekly address, President Obama said our economy is moving in the right direction. We have cut our deficits by more than half, businesses have created millions of new jobs, and we have taken significant steps to reverse our addiction to foreign oil and fix our broken health care system.

The audio of the address and video of the address will be available online at www.whitehouse.gov at 6:00 a.m. ET, November 23, 2013.

Remarks for President Barack Obama

Weekly Address

The White House

November 23, 2013

Hi, everybody.  Over the past couple months, most of the political headlines you’ve read have probably been about the government shutdown and the launch of the Affordable Care Act.  And I know that many of you have rightly never been more frustrated with Washington.

But if you look beyond those headlines, there are some good things happening in our economy.  And that’s been my top priority since the day I walked into the Oval Office.

After decades in which the middle class was working harder and harder just to keep up, and a punishing recession that made it worse, we made the tough choices required not just to recover from crisis, but to rebuild on a new foundation for stronger, more durable economic growth.

Five years later, we have fought our way back.  Our businesses have created 7.8 million new jobs in the past 44 months.  Another 200,000 Americans went back to work last month.

The American auto industry has come roaring back with more than 350,000 new jobs – jobs churning out and selling the high-tech, fuel-efficient cars the world wants to buy.  And they’re leading the charge in a manufacturing sector that has added jobs for the first time since the 1990s – a big reason why our businesses sell more goods and services “Made in America” than ever before.

We decided to reverse our addiction to foreign oil.  And today, we generate more renewable energy than ever, more natural gas than anybody, and for the first time in nearly 20 years, America now produces more oil than we buy from other countries.

We decided to fix a broken health care system.  And even though the rollout of the marketplace where you can buy affordable plans has been rough, so far, about 500,000 Americans are poised to gain health coverage starting January 1st.  And by the way, health care costs are growing at the slowest rate in 50 years.

And one more thing: since I took office, we’ve cut our deficits by more than half.  And that makes it easier to invest in the things that create jobs – education, research, and infrastructure.

Imagine how much farther along we could be if both parties were working together.  Think about what we could do if a reckless few didn’t hold the economy hostage every few months, or waste time on dozens of votes to repeal the Affordable Care Act rather than try to help us fix it. 

In the weeks ahead, I’ll keep talking about my plan to build a better bargain for the middle class.  Good jobs.  A good education.  A chance to buy a home, save, and retire.  And yes, the financial security of affordable health care.  And I’ll look for any willing partners who want to help.

Because of your hard work and tough sacrifices over the past five years, we’re pointed in the right direction.  But we’ve got more work to do to keep moving that way.  And as long as I’m President, I’ll keep doing everything I can to create jobs, grow the economy, and make sure that everyone who works hard has a chance to get ahead.  Thanks, and have a great weekend.

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by the President at Champions of Change ConnectED Event

South Court Auditorium

2:28 P.M. EST

THE PRESIDENT:  Well, hello, everybody.  Have a seat, have a seat.  And thank you, Misa, for the introduction and, more importantly, what you are doing in the classroom every single day, which is making such a big difference.  And I want to welcome all of you who are here.  This is one of my favorite events we do periodically.  It gives me an opportunity to say thanks and recognize people who are making extraordinary contributions in their local communities.  And we’re learning from you, seeing what works, seeing what has an impact. 

We call them Champions of Change:  people who have done some innovative work that hopefully can be replicated in other parts of the country once they have good models that are having success.  And today, we are honoring 10 educators who use technology to support one of our country’s top priorities, and that’s preparing our kids and our workers for the competition that they’re going to face in a 21st century global economy. 

In an age when the world’s information is just a click away, we’ve got to bring our schools and our libraries into the 21st century.  That’s why five months ago I launched an initiative that we’re calling ConnectED to bring high-speed Internet to 99 percent of American students over the next five years.  And this is going to be a top priority for me.  It’s going to take some hard work across my administration, but I’m committed to getting it done. 

Because this is not just about wiring schools; it’s about changing students’ lives.  It’s about using technology to give students a chance to learn at their own pace, whether they’re catching up on a subject or moving ahead to the next level.  It’s about giving teachers a better data set so they can see exactly what’s working and what isn’t for particular students.  It’s about unleashing a new market for educational devices and apps that will create jobs and spur innovation. 

And it’s about supporting outstanding, innovative educators like our Champions for Change.  Because of their work in North Dakota, young people with autism are using educational apps to discover abilities that they didn’t even know that they had.  In Colorado, preschoolers have now obtained access to a digital discovery center that helps them to get a great education from the earliest age.  In Georgia, students at an after-school technology club are learning skills that are going to help them succeed in college and throughout their careers.  And today’s Champions of Change are helping to give our students what every parent wants for their child -- the chance to go as far as their talents and hard work will take them.

So to all of our Champions for Change, we want to thank you for your extraordinary efforts.  As long as I’m President, I’m going to keep working not only to support the great work that educators and librarians are doing across the country but more fundamentally to make sure that young people are getting every opportunity that they deserve to thrive and succeed in this modern economy.  And I see some young people here and they look like they’re doing pretty good.  (Laughter.)  Although they may be bored by me making too long a speech.  (Laughter.)

Thank you very much, everybody. 

END
2:34 P.M. EST

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by the President at the 50th Anniversary of the Presidential Medal of Freedom

National Museum of American History

7:26 P.M. EST

THE PRESIDENT:  Good evening, everybody.  Please have a seat.  Michelle and I are so pleased to join you tonight to honor the legacy of an American leader in a building dedicated to the preservation of our American history. 

And we are thrilled to be joined by so many people whose accomplishments helped write new chapters in that history.  This morning, I recognized 16 brilliant, compassionate, wildly talented people with the Presidential Medal of Freedom, the nation’s highest civilian award.  And that was intimidating enough.  Tonight, I’m facing dozens of you. 

To the Presidential Medal of Freedom recipients of this year and years past, it is a great honor to be with you for this anniversary celebration.  To Wayne Clough, thank you for hosting us and for all the Smithsonian does to enrich our cultural heritage.  And to Jack, I have to say that our new ambassador to Japan, I’m sure, would be pleased with how you performed this evening.  I’ll give her a full report.  (Laughter.)  To all the family members of the Kennedy family, we are grateful for your presence and your enduring contributions to the life of our country.

For centuries, awards have existed for military valor.  And fifty years ago, President John F. Kennedy established a way to award extraordinary civilian virtue -- contributions to our country, service to our democracy, a dedication to our humanity that has advanced the common interest of freedom-loving people, both here at home and around the world. 

Since its creation, the Presidential Medal of Freedom has paid tribute to the creativity of writers, and artists, and entertainers.  We’ve recognized the leadership of elected officials and civil rights organizers; the imagination of scientists and business leaders; the grit and determination of our astronauts and our athletes.   Because there is no one way to contribute to the success of America.  What makes us great is that we believe in a certain set of values that encourage freedom of expression and aspiration.  We celebrate imagination and education and occasional rebellion.  And we refuse to set limits on what we can do or who we can be. 

Other peoples in other times have marked their history by moments of conquest at war, by dominion over empires.  But in the arc of human history, the American experience stands apart, because our triumph is not simply found in the exertion of our power; it’s found in the example of our people. Our particular genius over 237 years has been something more than the sum of our individual excellence, but rather a culmination of our common endeavors.

It’s a truth that resonated with President Kennedy when he said, “…I am certain that after the dust of centuries has passed over our cities, we…will be remembered not for our victories or defeats in battle or in politics, but for our contribution to the human spirit.”

And that unbending belief -- that the power to make great a nation is found in its people and in their freedom -- that was his philosophy.  That is his legacy. 

And it’s a legacy told in villages around the world that have clean water, or a new school, and a steady friend in the United States, thanks to the volunteers of the Peace Corps.  It’s a legacy found in the courage of all who serve under our proud flag, willing, like President Kennedy himself, to pay any price and bear any burden for the survival and success of our liberty. 

It’s a legacy on display in the arts and culture that he and Jackie championed as part of our national character, a legacy planted on the moon that he said that we’d visit and that we did, in the stars beyond, but also in the breakthroughs of the generations of scientists that his audacious promise inspired.

It’s a legacy continued by his brothers and his sisters, who have left this a more gentle and compassionate country.  Jean, a Medal of Freedom recipient herself and a diplomat in every sense, is with us tonight.  Bobby, whose wife, Ethel is one of my dearest friends, as Jack noted, would be celebrating Bobby’s 88th birthday today.  Eunice and Pat were devoted advocates for Americans of all abilities.  And Teddy, the youngest brother with the biggest heart -- he was a happy warrior who we were sent here to serve and waged a decades-long battle on behalf of those folks who sent us here -– for workers’ rights, and immigrants’ rights, and the right to affordable health care.  Tonight, our sympathies are with the love of Teddy’s life, Vicki, as she mourns the loss of her father, Judge Edmund Reggie. 

And it’s all tolled a legacy of service that the Kennedy family continues to this day -- from Caroline, who’s already drawing crowds of her own as she settles into her role as ambassador to Japan; to his great-nephew, and Massachusetts’ newest Congressman, Joe Kennedy; to the school of public service that bears the family name and teaches its young leaders how they, too, might one day pass the torch to a new generation.

This is a legacy of a man who could have retreated to a life of luxury and ease, but who chose to live a life in the arena -- sailing sometimes against the wind, sometimes with it.  And that’s why, 50 years later, John F. Kennedy stands for posterity as he did in life -- young, and bold, and daring.  And he stays with us in our imagination not because he left us too soon, but because he embodied the character of the people he led.  Resilient, resolute.  Fearless and fun-loving.  Defiant in the face of impossible odds and, most of all, determined to make the world anew -- not settling for what is but rather for what might be.  And in his idealism –- his sober, square-jawed idealism –- we are reminded that the power to change this country is ours.

This afternoon, Michelle and I were joined by President Clinton and Secretary Clinton to pay tribute to that proud legacy.  We had a chance to lay a wreath at the gravesite at Arlington, where President Kennedy is surrounded by his wife and younger brothers, and where he will rest in peace for all time, remembered not just for his victories in battle or in politics, but for the words he uttered all those years ago:  “We…will be remembered…for our contribution to the human spirit.”

How blessed we are to live in a country where these contributions overflow in ways both heralded and not so heralded.  The thousands of people in San Francisco who helped a little boy recovering from cancer live out his superhero dreams -- that’s part of that spirit.  The Marines deploying relief after a devastating typhoon and all across an ocean, people checking on their neighbors after a tornado; the families across the country who will spend Thanksgiving Day cooking feasts so others less fortunate might eat -- that’s part of the spirit. 

That’s who we are -- a people whose greatness comes not by settling for what we can achieve in our own lives, but also because we dare to ask what we can do, as citizens, to contribute to this grand experiment we call America.

And that’s what our Presidential Medal of Freedom honorees embody, each and every one of them who are here today and those who we remember posthumously.  That’s the living legacy of the Kennedy family.  And that is the responsibility we all welcome, as Americans, for our lifetime on this planet.

We are extraordinarily blessed to be Americans because we have the opportunity to serve in ways that so many of you have served, because we have the opportunity to touch lives in the ways that so many of you have touched lives.

God bless you all, and God bless the United States of America.

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by the President at Presidential Medal of Freedom Ceremony

East Room

11:17 A.M. EST

THE PRESIDENT:  Good morning!  (Applause.)  Good morning, everybody!  Everybody, please have a seat.  Have a seat.

Well, on behalf of Michelle and myself, welcome to the White House.  This is one of my favorite events every year, especially special this year, as I look at this extraordinary group of individuals and our opportunity to honor them with our nation’s highest civilian honor -- the Presidential Medal of Freedom. 

And this year, it’s just a little more special because this marks the 50th anniversary of President Kennedy establishing this award.  We’re honored, by the way, today to have with us one of my favorite people -- Ethel Kennedy -- and a pretty good basketball player, President Kennedy’s grandson, Jack.  (Applause.)  

This medal has been bestowed on more than 500 deserving people.  Tonight, I’m looking forward to joining some of these honorees, as well as members of the Kennedy family, as we pay tribute to these 50 years of excellence.  And this morning, we’re honored to add 16 new names to this distinguished list. 

Today, we salute fierce competitors who became true champions.  In the sweltering heat of a Chicago summer, Ernie Banks walked into the Cubs locker room and didn’t like what he saw.  “Everybody was sitting around, heads down, depressed,” he recalled.  So Ernie piped up and said, “Boy, what a great day!  Let’s play two!”  (Laughter.)  That’s “Mr. Cub” -- a man who came up through the Negro Leagues, making $7 a day, and became the first black player to suit up for the Cubs and one of the greatest hitters of all time.  And in the process, Ernie became known as much for his 512 home runs as for his cheer and his optimism and his eternal faith that someday the Cubs would go all the way.  (Laughter.)   

And that's serious belief.  (Laughter.)  That is something that even a White Sox fan like me can respect.  (Laughter.)  But he is just a wonderful man and a great icon of my hometown.
 
Speaking of sports, Dean Smith is one of the winningest coaches in college basketball history, but his successes go far beyond Xs and Os.  Even as he won 78 percent of his games, he graduated 96 percent of his players.  The first coach to use multiple defenses in a game, he was the pioneer who popularized the idea of “pointing to the passer” -- after a basket, players should point to the teammate who passed them the ball.  And with his first national title on the line, he did have the good sense to give the ball to a 19-year-old kid named Michael Jordan.  (Laughter.)  Although they used to joke that the only person who ever held Michael under 20 was Dean Smith.  (Laughter.)   

While Coach Smith couldn’t join us today due to an illness that he’s facing with extraordinary courage, we also honor his courage in helping to change our country -- he recruited the first black scholarship athlete to North Carolina and helped to integrate a restaurant and a neighborhood in Chapel Hill.  That's the kind of character that he represented on and off the court.

We salute innovators who pushed the limits of science, changing how we see the world -- and ourselves.  And growing up, Sally Ride read about the space program in the newspaper almost every day, and she thought this was “the coolest thing around.”  When she was a PhD candidate at Stanford she saw an ad for astronauts in the student newspaper and she seized the opportunity.  As the first American woman in space, Sally didn’t just break the stratospheric glass ceiling, she blasted through it.  And when she came back to Earth, she devoted her life to helping girls excel in fields like math, science and engineering.  “Young girls need to see role models,” she said, “you can’t be what you can’t see.”  Today, our daughters -- including Malia and Sasha -- can set their sights a little bit higher because Sally Ride showed them the way.

Now, all of us have moments when we look back and wonder, “What the heck was I thinking?”  I have that -- (laughter) -- quite a bit.  Psychologist Daniel Kahneman has made that simple question his life’s work.  In a storied career in Israel and America, he basically invented the study of human decision-making.  He’s helped us to understand everything from behavioral economics to “Does living in California make people happy?”  It’s an interesting question.  He’s also been called an expert on irrational behavior -- so I'm sure that he could shed some light on Washington.  (Laughter.) 

But what truly sets Daniel apart is his curiosity.  Guided by his belief that people are “endlessly complicated and interesting,” at 79 he’s still discovering new insights into how we think and learn, not just so we understand each other, but so we can work and live together more effectively. 

Dr. Mario Molina’s love of science started as a young boy in Mexico City, in a homemade laboratory in a bathroom at home.  And that passion for discovery led Mario to become one of the most respected chemists of his era.  He was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize -- or the Nobel Prize, rather, not only for his path-breaking research, but also for his insistence that when we ignore dangerous carbon emissions we risk destroying the ozone layer and endangering our planet.  And thanks to Mario’s work, the world came together to address a common threat, and today, inspired by his example, we’re working to leave our planet safer and cleaner for future generations.

We also have to salute musicians, who bring such joy to our lives.  Loretta Lynn was 19 the first time she won the big -- she won big at the local fair.  Her canned vegetables brought home 17 blue ribbons -- (laughter) -- and made her “Canner of the Year.” (Laughter.)  Now, that’s impressive.  (Laughter.) 

For a girl from Butcher Hollow, Kentucky, that was fame.  Fortunately for all of us, she decided to try her hand at things other than canning.  Her first guitar cost $17, and with it this coal miner’s daughter gave voice to a generation, singing what no one wanted to talk about and saying what no one wanted to think about.  And now, over 50 years after she cut her first record -- and canned her first vegetables -- (laughter) -- Loretta Lynn still reigns as the rule-breaking, record-setting queen of country music. 

As a young man in Cuba, Arturo Sandoval loved jazz so much it landed him in jail.  It was the Cold War, and the only radio station where he could hear jazz was the Voice of America, which was dangerous to listen to.  But Arturo listened anyway.  Later, he defected to the United States knowing he might never see his parents or beloved homeland again.  “Without freedom,” he said, “there is no life.”  And today, Arturo is an American citizen and one of the most celebrated trumpet players in the world.  “There isn’t any place on Earth where the people don’t know about jazz,” he says, and that’s true in part because musicians like him have sacrificed so much to play it.

We salute pioneers who pushed our nation towards greater justice and equality.  A Baptist minister, C.T. Vivian was one of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s closest advisors.  “Martin taught us,” he says, “that it’s in the action that we find out who we really are.”  And time and again, Reverend Vivian was among the first to be in the action:  In 1947, joining a sit-in to integrate an Illinois restaurant; one of the first Freedom Riders; in Selma, on the courthouse steps to register blacks to vote, for which he was beaten, bloodied and jailed.  Rosa Parks said of him, “Even after things had supposedly been taken care of and we had our rights, he was still out there, inspiring the next generation, including me,” helping kids go to college with a program that would become Upward Bound.  And at 89 years old, Reverend Vivian is still out there, still in the action, pushing us closer to our founding ideals.

Now, early in the morning the day of the March on Washington, the National Mall was far from full and some in the press were beginning to wonder if the event would be a failure.  But the march’s chief organizer, Bayard Rustin, didn’t panic.  As the story goes, he looked down at a piece of paper, looked back up, and reassured reporters that everything was right on schedule.  The only thing those reporters didn’t know was that the paper he was holding was blank.  (Laughter.)  He didn’t know how it was going to work out, but Bayard had an unshakable optimism, nerves of steel, and, most importantly, a faith that if the cause is just and people are organized, nothing can stand in our way. 

So, for decades, this great leader, often at Dr. King’s side, was denied his rightful place in history because he was openly gay.  No medal can change that, but today, we honor Bayard Rustin’s memory by taking our place in his march towards true equality, no matter who we are or who we love.  (Applause.)

Speaking of game-changers, disrupters, there was a young girl names Gloria Steinem who arrived in New York to make her mark as a journalist, and magazines only wanted to write articles like “How to Cook without Really Cooking for Men.”  (Laughter.)  Gloria noticed things like that.  (Laughter.)  She’s been called a “champion noticer.”  She’s alert to all the ways, large and small, that women had been and, in some cases, continue to be treated unfairly just because they’re women. 

As a writer, a speaker, an activist, she awakened a vast and often skeptical public to problems like domestic violence, the lack of affordable child care, unfair hiring practices.  And because of her work, across America and around the world, more women are afforded the respect and opportunities that they deserve.  But she also changed how women thought about themselves.  And Gloria continues to pour her heart into teaching and mentoring.  Her one piece of advice to young girls is -- I love this -- “Do not listen to my advice.  Listen to the voice inside you and follow that.” 

When Patricia Wald’s law firm asked if she’d come back after having her first child, she said she’d like some time off to focus on her family -- devoted almost 10 years to raising five children.  But Patricia never lost the itch to practice law.  So while her husband watched the kids at home, she’d hit the library on weekends.  At the age 40, she went back to the courtroom to show the “young kids” a thing or two.  As the first female judge on the D.C. Circuit, Patricia was a top candidate for Attorney General.  After leaving the bench, her idea of retirement was to go to The Hague to preside over the trials of war criminals.  Patricia says she hopes enough women will become judges that “it’s not worth celebrating” anymore.  But today, we celebrate her.  And along with Gloria, she shows there are all kinds of paths listening to your own voice.
We salute communicators who shined a light on stories no one else was telling.  A veteran of World War II and more than a dozen Pacific battles, Ben Bradlee brought the same intensity and dedication to journalism.  Since joining The Washington Post 65 years ago, he transformed that newspaper into one of the finest in the world.  With Ben in charge, the Post published the Pentagon Papers, revealing the true history of America’s involvement in Vietnam; exposed Watergate; unleashed a new era of investigative journalism, holding America’s leaders accountable and reminding us that our freedom as a nation rests on our freedom of the press.  When Ben retired, Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan put the admiration of many into a poem:  “O rare Ben Bradlee/His reign has ceased/But his nation stands/Its strength increased.”

And I also indicated to Ben he can pull off those shirts and I can't.  (Laughter.)  He always looks so cool in them.  (Laughter.) 
Early in Oprah Winfrey’s career, her bosses told her she should change her name to Susie.  (Laughter.)  I have to pause here to say I got the same advice.  (Laughter and applause.)  They didn't say I should be named "Susie," but they suggested I should change my name.  (Laughter.)  People can relate to Susie, that's what they said.  It turned out, surprisingly, that people could relate to Oprah just fine. 
In more than 4,500 episodes of her show, her message was always, "You can."  "You can do and you can be and you can grow and it can be better."  And she was living proof, rising from a childhood of poverty and abuse to the pinnacle of the entertainment universe.  But even with 40 Emmys, the distinction of being the first black female billionaire, Oprah’s greatest strength has always been her ability to help us discover the best in ourselves.  Michelle and I count ourselves among her many devoted fans and friends.  As one of those fans wrote, “I didn’t know I had a light in me until Oprah told me it was there.”  What a great gift.
And, finally, we salute public servants who’ve strengthened our nation.  Daniel Inouye was a humble man and didn’t wear his Medal of Honor very often.  Instead, he liked to wear a pin representing the Good Conduct Medal he earned as a teenage private.  “To behave yourself takes special effort,” he said,  “and I did not want to dishonor my family.”  Danny always honored his family and his country, even when his country didn’t always honor him. 
After being classified as an “enemy alien,” Danny joined a Japanese American unit that became one of the most decorated in World War II.  And as the second-longest serving senator in American history, he showed a generation of young people -- including one kid with a funny name growing up in Hawaii who noticed that there was somebody during some of those hearings in Washington that didn't look like everybody else, which meant maybe I had a chance to do something important, too.  He taught all of us that no matter what you look like or where you come from, this country has a place for everybody who’s willing to serve and work hard.
A proud Hoosier, Dick Lugar has served America for more than half a century, from a young Navy lieutenant to a respected leader in the United States Senate.  I’ll always be thankful to Dick for taking me -- a new, junior senator -- under his wing, including travels together to review some of his visionary work, the destruction of Cold War arsenals in the former Soviet Union  -- something that doesn’t get a lot of public notice, but was absolutely critical to making us safer in the wake of the Cold War.
Now, I should say, traveling with Dick you get close to unexploded landmines, mortar shells, test tubes filled with anthrax and the plague.  (Laughter.)  His legacy, though, is the thousands of missiles and bombers and submarines and warheads that no longer threaten us because of his extraordinary work.  And our nation and our world are safer because of this statesman. And in a time of unrelenting partisanship, Dick Lugar’s decency, his commitment to bipartisan problem-solving, stand as a model of what public service ought to be.  
Now, last, but never least, we honor a leader who we still remember with such extraordinary fondness.  He still remembers as a child waving goodbye to his mom -- tears in her eyes -- as she went off to nursing school so she could provide for her family.  And I think lifting up families like his own became the story of Bill Clinton’s life.  He remembered what his mom had to do on behalf of him and he wanted to make sure that he made life better and easier for so many people all across the country that were struggling in those same ways and had those same hopes and dreams.  So as a governor, he transformed education so more kids could pursue those dreams.  As President, he proved that, with the right choices, you could grow the economy, lift people out of poverty.  We could shrink our deficits and still invest in our families, our health, our schools, science, technology.  In other words, we can go farther when we look out for each other. 

And as we’ve all seen, as President, he was just getting started.  He doesn’t stop.  He’s helped lead relief efforts after the Asian tsunami, Hurricane Katrina, the Haiti earthquake.  His foundation and global initiative have helped to save or improve the lives of literally hundreds of millions of people.  And, of course, I am most grateful for his patience during the endless travels of my Secretary of State.  (Laughter.) 

So I’m grateful, Bill, as well for the advice and counsel that you’ve offered me on and off the golf course.  (Laughter.)  And most importantly, for your lifesaving work around the world, which represents what’s the very best in America.  So thank you so much, President Clinton.  (Applause.)

So these are the recipients of the 2013 Presidential Medal of Freedom.  These are the men and women who in their extraordinary lives remind us all of the beauty of the human spirit, the values that define us as Americans, the potential that lives inside of all of us.  I could not be more happy and more honored to participate in this ceremony here today.

With that, what I would like to do is invite our honorees to just sit there and let all of us stand and give you a big round of applause.  (Applause.) 

I guess we should actually give them the medals, though.  (Laughter.)  Where are my -- here we go.  Lee, you want to hit it?

MILITARY AIDE:  Presidential Medal of Freedom recipients.

Ernie Banks.  (Applause.)  With an unmatched enthusiasm for America’s pastime, Ernie Banks slugged, sprinted and smiled his way into the record books.  Known to fans as “Mr. Cub,” he played an extraordinary 19 seasons with the Chicago Cubs, during which he was named to 11 All-Star teams, hit over 500 home runs, and won back-to-back Most Valuable Player honors.  Ernie Banks was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1977, and he will forever be known as one of the finest power hitters and most dynamic players of all time.  (Applause.)  

Benjamin Crowninshield Bradlee.  (Applause.)  A titan of journalism, Benjamin Crowninshield Bradlee is one of the most respected newsmen of his generation.  After serving our nation in World War II, Ben Bradlee went on to defend liberty here at home. Testing the limits of a free press during his tenure as executive editor of The Washington Post, he oversaw coverage of the Watergate scandal and successfully challenged the federal government over the right to publish the Pentagon Papers. His passion for accuracy and unyielding pursuit of truth continue to set the standard for journalism.  (Applause.) 

The Honorable William J. Clinton.  (Applause.)  Among the finest public servants of our time, President William J. Clinton argued cases for the people of Arkansas, served his state in the Governor’s Mansion, and guided our nation into a new century.  As the 42nd President of the United States, Bill Clinton oversaw an era of challenge and change, prosperity and progress.  His work after leaving public office continues to reflect his passionate, unending commitment to improving the lives and livelihoods of people around the world.  In responding to needs both at home and abroad, and as founder of the Clinton Foundation, he has shown that through creative cooperation among women and men of goodwill, we can solve even the most intractable problems.  (Applause.) 

Irene Hirano Inouye, accepting on behalf of her husband, the Honorable Daniel K. Inouye.  (Applause.)  A true patriot and dedicated public servant, Daniel K. Inouye understood the power of leaders when united in common purpose to protect and promote the tenets we cherish as Americans.  As a member of the revered 442nd Regimental Combat Team, Daniel Inouye helped free Europe from the grasp of tyranny during World War II, for which he received the Medal of Honor.  Representing the people of Hawaii from the moment the islands joined the Union, he never lost sight of the ideals that bind us across the 50 states.  Senator Inouye’s reason and resolve helped make our country what it is today, and for that, we honor him.  (Applause.) 

Dr. Daniel Kahneman.  (Applause.)  Daniel Kahneman’s groundbreaking work earned him a Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences for his research developing prospect theory.  After escaping from Nazi-occupied France as a young boy and later joining the Israel Defense Forces, Dr. Kahneman grew interested in understanding the origins of people’s beliefs.  Combining psychology and economic analysis, and working alongside Dr. Amos Tversky, Dr. Kahneman used simple experiments to demonstrate how people make decisions under uncertain circumstances, and he forever changed the way we view human judgment.  (Applause.) 

The Honorable Richard G. Lugar.  (Applause.)  Representing the State of Indiana for over three decades in the United States Senate, Richard G. Lugar put country above party and self to forge bipartisan consensus.  Throughout his time in the Senate, he offered effective solutions to our national and international problems, advocating for the control of nuclear arms and other weapons of mass destruction.  Working with Senator Sam Nunn, Richard Lugar established the Nunn-Lugar Cooperative Threat Reduction Program, one of our country’s most successful national security initiatives, helping to sustain American leadership and engage nations in collaboration after decades of confrontation.  He remains a strong voice on foreign policy issues, and his informed perspective will have broad influence for years to come. (Applause.) 

Loretta Lynn.  (Applause.)  Born a coal miner’s daughter, Loretta Lynn has followed a bold path to become a legend in country music.  A singer, songwriter, and author, she has written dozens of chart-topping songs, released scores of albums, and won numerous accolades.  Breaking barriers in country music and entertainment, she opened doors for women not only by winning tremendous achievements, but also by raising issues few dared to discuss.  Fearlessly telling her own stories with candor and humor, Loretta Lynn has brought a strong female voice to mainstream music, captured the emotions of women and men alike, and revealed the common truths about life as it is lived.  (Applause.)  

Dr. Mario Molina.  (Applause.)  The curiosity and creativity that inspired Mario Molina to convert his family’s bathroom into a laboratory as a child have driven him through decades of scientific research.  Born in Mexico, Dr. Molina’s passion for chemistry brought him to the United States, where his investigations of chlorofluorocarbons led to breakthroughs in our understanding of how they deplete the ozone layer.  The impact of his discoveries extends far beyond his field, affecting environmental policy and fostering international awareness, as well as earning him the 1995 Nobel Prize in Chemistry.  Today, Dr. Molina remains a global leader, continuing to study air quality, climate change, and the environment that connects us all.  (Applause.)

Tam O’Shaughnessy accepting on behalf of her life partner, Dr. Sally K. Ride.  (Applause.)  Thirty years ago, Dr. Sally K. Ride soared into space as the youngest American and first woman to wear the Stars and Stripes above Earth’s atmosphere.  As an astronaut, she sought to keep America at the forefront of space exploration.  As a role model, she fought tirelessly to inspire young people -- especially girls -- to become scientifically literate and to pursue careers in science, technology, engineering, and math.  At the end of her life, she became an inspiration for those battling pancreatic cancer, and for the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender community.  The tale of a quiet hero, Sally Ride’s story demonstrates that the sky is no limit for those who dream of reaching for the stars.  (Applause.)

Walter Naegle accepting on behalf of his partner, Bayard Rustin.  (Applause.)  Bayard Rustin was a giant in the American Civil Rights Movement.  Openly gay at a time when many had to hide who they loved, his unwavering belief that we are all equal members of a “single human family” took him from his first Freedom Ride to the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender rights movement.  Thanks to his unparalleled skills as an organizer, progress that once seemed impossible appears, in retrospect, to have been inevitable.  Fifty years after the March on Washington he organized, America honors Bayard Rustin as one of its greatest architects for social change and a fearless advocate for its most vulnerable citizens.  (Applause.)  

Arturo Sandoval.  (Applause.)  Arturo Sandoval is one of the world’s finest jazz musicians.  Born into poverty in Cuba and held back by his government, he risked everything to share his gifts with the world -- eventually defecting with help from Dizzy Gillespie, his mentor and friend.  In the decades since, this astonishing trumpeter, pianist, and composer has inspired audiences in every corner of the world and awakened a new generation of great performers.  He remains one of the best ever to play.  (Applause.)

Linnea Smith, accepting on behalf of her husband, Dean E. Smith.  (Applause.)  Dean E. Smith spent 36 seasons taking college basketball to new heights.  As head coach at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, he led his team to 11 Final Fours, two national titles, and 879 victories, retiring as the winningest men’s college basketball coach in history.  Dean Smith brought the same commitment to supporting his players off the court.  He helped more than 96 percent of his lettermen graduate.  And in an era of deep division, he taught players to overcome bigotry with courage and compassion.  He will forever stand as one of the greatest coaches in college basketball history.  (Applause.)

Gloria Steiner.  (Applause.)  A trailblazing writer and feminist organizer, Gloria Steinem has been at the forefront of the fight for equality and social justice for more than four decades.  Instrumental to a broad range of initiatives and issues, from establishing Ms. Magazine and Take Our Daughters to Work Day, to pushing for women’s self-empowerment and an end to sex trafficking.  She has promoted lasting political and social change in America and abroad.  Through her reporting and speaking, she has shaped debates on the intersection of sex and race, brought critical problems to national attention, and forged new opportunities for women in media.  Gloria Steinem continues to move us all to take up the cause of reaching for a more just tomorrow.  (Applause.)

Reverend C.T. Vivian.  (Applause.)  Equipped only with courage and an overwhelming commitment to social justice, the Reverend C.T. Vivian was a stalwart activist on the march toward racial equality.  Whether at a lunch counter, on a Freedom Ride, or behind the bars of a prison cell, he was unafraid to take bold action in the face of fierce resistance.  By pushing change through nonviolent demonstration and advocacy, C.T. Vivian established and led numerous organizations to support underserved individuals and communities.  His legacy of combating injustice will shine as an example for generations to come.  (Applause.)

Patricia McGowan Wald.  (Applause.)  Patricia McGowan Wald made history as the first woman appointed to the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.  Rising to Chief Judge of the Court, she always strove to better understand the law and fairly apply it.  After leaving federal service, Judge Wald helped institute standards for justice and the rule of law at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia in The Hague.  Hailed as a model judge, she laid a foundation for countless women within the legal profession and helped unveil the humanity within the law.  (Applause.)

Oprah G. Winfrey.  (Applause.)  Oprah G. Winfrey is a global media icon.  When she launched The Oprah Winfrey Show in 1986, there were few women -- and even fewer women of color -- with a national platform to discuss the issues and events shaping our times.  But over the 25 years that followed, Oprah Winfrey’s innate gift for tapping into our most fervent hopes and deepest fears drew millions of viewers across every background, making her show the highest-rated talk show in television history.  Off screen, Oprah Winfrey has used her influence to support underserved communities and to lift up the lives of young people -- especially young women -- around the world.  In her story, we are reminded that no dream can be deferred when we refuse to let life’s obstacles keep us down.  (Applause.)

THE PRESIDENT:  The Medal of Freedom honorees -- please.  (Applause.) 

Well, that concludes the formal part of today’s ceremony.  I want to thank all of you for being here.  Obviously, we are deeply indebted to those who we honor here today.  And we’re going to have an opportunity to take some pictures with the honorees and their family members. 

The rest of you, I understand the food here is pretty good. (Laughter.)  So I hope you enjoy the reception, and I hope we carry away from this a reminder of what JFK understood to be the essence of the American spirit -- that it’s represented here.  And some of us may be less talented, but we all have the opportunity to serve and to open people’s hearts and minds in our smaller orbits.  So I hope everybody has been as inspired, as I have been, participating and being with these people here today.

Thank you very much, everybody.  (Applause.)

END
12:00 P.M. EST

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks As Prepared for Delivery By Assistant to the President for Homeland Security and Counterterrorism Lisa Monaco

Good afternoon—thank you so much, Andrew [Weissmann].  It’s always a good rule of thumb to have a friend introduce you, and Andrew and I go back a long way.  We’re here today to discuss a critical topic at a critical time, and I’d like to thank everyone at NYU Law and the Center on Law and Security, especially Sam Rascoff and Zach Goldman, for inviting me to be part of this conference. 

It strikes me that NYU’s motto is particularly appropriate for the topic at hand:  Perstare et praestare.  To persevere and to excel.  That motto reflects how the men and women of the counterterrorism community approach their mission every day.

Protecting Americans at home and abroad is our first responsibility as a government, and the President’s first responsibility as Commander-in-Chief.  My job as the President’s homeland security and counterterrorism advisor is to wake up every morning thinking about how to confront the array of transnational and unconventional threats our nation faces. 

So many of you are drawn to this topic because of what happened 12 years ago in this proud city, and at the Pentagon and in the skies above Pennsylvania.  For many in the NYU community, the attack wasn’t just a national tragedy, it was a personal trauma.  You lived it.  We can never forget the clouds of ash that blotted out a September sun, the twisted steel that scarred Lower Manhattan, or the gaping hole left in our hearts by the thousands we lost.  That’s why, over the past 12 years and across two different administrations, thoughtful people have come together in settings like these to help shape the response to the many challenges—legal, ethical, strategic—that we have faced in confronting evolving threats.  Events like these have helped to shape our national response, and today, I can tell you that this nation has developed an expertise in counterterrorism that is unequalled.  We’ve persevered in our fight against extremism, and we’ve exceled at our mission to identify threats and prevent attacks. 

Our approach reflects a comprehensive—and tailored—CT strategy; one that draws on all elements of our national power.  This strategy must be precise and sustainable—it cannot rely on open-ended war that drains our resources and risks undermining national consensus on combatting terrorist organizations.  As President Obama said in his speech at the National Defense University in May, “We must define our effort not as a boundless ‘global war on terror,’ but rather as a series of persistent, targeted efforts to dismantle specific networks of violent extremists that threaten America.”  If we do that, I have no doubt that we can defend our nation and emerge even stronger.

We’re at a law school, so it’s appropriate to talk about the “theory of the case.”  When it comes to confronting terrorism threats today, our theory of the case is about partnerships.  This element of our strategy often gets lost in all the focus on direct action taken with drones or special operations forces.  To succeed—and to be sustainable—we need an approach that goes beyond direct action.  Our strategy reflects a commitment to partner with host nations, with allies, and across the expertise in our own government to confront an increasingly diverse and diffuse terrorist threat.

That doesn’t mean we’re taking our foot off the gas when it comes to pursuing terrorist groups that threaten our nation.  Far from scaling back our counterterrorism operations, our special operators, intelligence and law enforcement professionals are more integrated and more effective than ever.  That integration and tempo of operations was on full display last month when over the course of a few days, the U.S. government executed a series of operations targeting specific threats —including an attempted capture of an al-Shabaab leader in Somalia, the successful capture of Abu Anas al-Libi—indicted for his alleged role in al-Qaeda’s conspiracy to kill Americans, including the bombings of our embassies in Kenya and Tanzania 15 years ago.  These actions send the message loud and clear:  We will use every tool at our disposal to prevent an attack against the United States or go after those who seek to do us harm—no matter how long it takes.  

Today, I want to discuss the full range of activities we undertake to protect the American people.  To disrupt, dismantle and defeat al Qaeda, its affiliates and adherents, while preserving American values, all of these pieces must work together. 

Threat

As this conference recognizes, we live in an era of evolving threats.  A host of factors—from political upheaval in the Middle East to easy access to information—have spawned a more diverse terrorist threat than we faced a decade ago.  The group that attacked us on 9/11—core al-Qaeda—is a shadow of its former self, and we continue to degrade its capacity.  While it remains intent on attacks against the U.S. homeland, its ability to mount a successful operation inside our borders is significantly diminished thanks to the work of CT professionals from all over the world.  Al Qaeda core’s leaders now spend more time hiding than plotting attacks.  In their place, more dispersed terrorist elements have taken on greater prominence in the fight. 

First, there are the regional al-Qaeda affiliates.  Chief among them is al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula–the most ambitious and active affiliate.  It has tried—and failed—to attack the U.S. homeland three separate times.  And it was a serious threat from the Arabian Peninsula that prompted us to temporarily close our embassies in the region over the summer. 

In Somalia, al-Shabaab is under pressure but still capable of sowing havoc, as we saw in the Westgate mall attack in Nairobi earlier this fall.  Some of its members remain committed to attacking the United States.  Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb controlled parts of Mali last year. And figures connected to the group, like Mokhtar Belmokhtar, seek to terrorize innocent civilians, as we saw last January in the hostage situation at the In Amenas gas plant.  And we are deeply concerned about a spike in threats from al-Qaeda in Iraq and groups like al-Nusrah Front in Syria that are intent on exploiting regional instability to gain a foothold in the Middle East.  Syria is one of the most difficult CT challenges on the horizon, and it will require coordinated international action to resolve.  

For the most part, the ambitions of these groups are regional and attacks are localized, but they remain a very real threat to U.S. interests.  They may not yet be capable of conducting large-scale attacks against the U.S. homeland, but they are actively targeting American embassies, assets, businesses, and citizens in their reach. 

A second category of threats are those loosely aligned groups who are not al-Qaeda affiliates but who subscribe to al-Qaeda’s ideology.  In recent years, these adherents have become increasingly active.  They are opportunistic—leveraging  economic and political instability in the Middle East and Africa, porous borders awash in weapons, and the confluence of nationalism and extremism to advance their own objectives.  They are perfectly willing to use violence to achieve a political goal or expand their territory. 

The clearest example is the violent extremists in Libya.  The Libyan people largely reject extremism, and they are working hard to throw off a legacy of dictatorship and to build a democratic government from the ground up. 

But strong institutions are not yet in place—including security forces—that can serve Libya’s citizens.  The United States is working to support progress in Libya, including with our NATO Allies to provide training to Libya’s armed forces.  But it will take years of steady effort and hard work.  Meanwhile, extremists groups like Ansar al-Sharia are able to exploit the lack of strong institutions to cause real damage and forestall progress.  It was in this environment where terrorists attacked our facilities in Benghazi last year and killed four brave Americans.  We remain concerned about instability and extremist influence in the country, even as we recognize that we have a good partner in Prime Minister Zeidan.     

The third category of threat is the most unpredictable—extremists who self-radicalize here in the United States, sometimes without any personal contact with al-Qaeda, beyond perhaps consuming their online propaganda.  Attacks like we saw in Boston last spring are not unstoppable, but the self-contained nature of this threat presents an added layer of difficulty for those who work nonstop to detect them.

That’s not an exhaustive list of every terrorist group and threat we’re tracking, of course.  Iran and Lebanese Hizballah operate around the globe; Boko Haram and Ansaru in West Africa; extremist groups in South and Southeast Asia; and we are always vigilant against domestic terrorism.  And, every terrorist group does not pose the same level of threat to the United States.  As the threat has become decentralized, we must be disciplined in differentiating between groups that pose a threat where they exist, and groups that have the will and capacity to project power.  But since 9/11, the threat is marked by more decentralization, more diverse actors, more attacks of opportunism. 

Strategy

So how are we addressing this dynamic threat?  We’re pursuing a multi-faceted strategy that includes our military, diplomacy, financial action, intelligence and law enforcement.  And in each of these areas, we are building partnerships that span borders:  soldier-to-soldier, cop-to-cop, prosecutor-to prosecutor, diplomat-to-diplomat.  

In all that we do, we rely on a comprehensive legal framework that brings all tools to bear: law enforcement, military, and intelligence.  This is seen in our use of both Article III courts as well as reformed military commissions in appropriate cases.  We gain valuable insights into the threats we face from intelligence collection using the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, as well as by executing search warrants and serving grand jury subpoenas.  And while we conduct operations under the Authorization to Use Military Force overseas, we also draw on law enforcement relationships and tools like Interpol “Red Notices,” to have terrorists arrested.  Not every tool will be appropriate for every threat.  But by integrating all of the tools, we ensure that our counterterrorism strategy is flexible enough to adapt as the threats change.

Architecture

Direct military action is a vital aspect of our CT strategy.  As President Obama has said, we will never hesitate to use force, including lethal force, if necessary, to protect the American people.  We take lethal action against terrorists who pose a continuing, imminent threat to the United States and its people.  But capture will always be the preferred course where feasible, and the President has shown his willingness to send in special operations units to capture individuals when a host nation cannot or will not take action.

These actions are conducted under strong oversight.  All strikes outside of Iraq and Afghanistan are briefed to the appropriate committees of Congress.  The actions are also legal.  Within a week of 9/11, Congress overwhelmingly passed the Authorization for the Use of Military Force, and as a matter of domestic and international law, the United States is at war with al Qaeda, the Taliban, and associated forces.  The AUMF has been a vital source of authority and it continues to be applicable to the threats we face today.  Over time, we will need to ensure our authorities reflect the specific needs of our current counterterrorism work.  That’s why the President is committed to working with Congress to refine, and ultimately repeal the mandate of the AUMF. 

Though CT direct action often dominates the headlines, it is only the proverbial tip of the spear.  If there is one factor that has defined our success over the past 12 years, it’s partnership.  Whether in Yemen or Iraq, Afghanistan or Pakistan, the Maghreb and Sahel, or in Europe, other governments often understand the root causes of terrorism in their countries and the weaknesses of our enemies better than we do.  They are often better positioned to provide sustained counterterrorism pressure.  We can provide training and equipment and share information, but our partners bring a knowledge, legitimacy and reach that amplifies our efforts.  These relationships help secure borders, degrade terrorist networks and take the fight to our enemies, wherever they hide.  That’s why we’ve built strong relationships to support every pillar of our counterterrorism architecture—starting with our military cooperation. 

Military partnership played out last year in North Africa when al Qaeda’s branch in Africa—AQIM—took control of much of north Mali.  Mali’s government was weakened by a coup, and loosely organized extremists exploited a power vacuum.  They combined easy access to weapons with a warped ideology.  They destroyed ancient treasures—including Muslim artifacts—and terrorized the local population.  So an international coalition, led by France and including support from the United States and partners in Europe, Africa and the Middle East, worked with the Malian military to drive the extremists out.  The U.S. provided airlift and refueling support, and we continue to supply critical needs, including food and water, and training, for more than 6,000 African soldiers and police who have been deployed since the beginning of the successful international response.  This international partnership paved the way for safe elections and renewed stability in Mali, taking on both the immediate threat and the dire conditions that helped the extremists take hold in the first place.   

That leads me to a second major pillar of our counterterrorism strategy: our international engagement to isolate terrorist groups and deny them resources. 

The UN Al-Qaeda sanctions regime, established unanimously under Security Council Resolution 1267, obligates member states to freeze the assets and prohibit travel of al Qaeda associates.  The Security Council has used this tool to impose sanctions on 221 individuals and 63 entities engaging in terrorism, raising funds, or providing other support to al Qaeda.  The global consensus and cooperation around these sanctions have limited the ability of bad actors to operate in the global financial system and, in many cases, to undertake terrorist acts across national borders.

Sulayman bu Ghayth was a terrorist designated on the UN list and a prominent member of al-Qaeda on 9/11.  When he tried to surreptitiously transit the globe earlier this year, he was detected and detained by our partners, allowing us to bring him to the United States to stand trial for his crimes.  And last week, we announced that we’ve added Boko Haram and Ansaru—deadly terror groups in Nigeria—to those designated as foreign terrorist organizations, another step in cutting off funding and other forms of support to growing terrorist threats.

We also work through mechanisms like the Financial Action Task Force.  Since 9/11, the United States has worked closely with the 35 other members of this group, including Russia and China, to clamp down on money laundering and combat the financing of terrorism.  This coalition has helped more than 40 countries—places like Nigeria, Morocco, and the Philippines—pass legislation to curb the flow of money to terrorist groups through banks and across borders. 

Of course, one of the most essential tools for tracking and disrupting terrorist plots is reliable intelligence and partnerships that allow us to share it.  That’s the third pillar of our counterterrorism structure.  Our strong intelligence cooperation with other nations is essential when it comes to taking on transnational terrorist networks, a fact foreign partners recognize as well as we do.  So, while public debate surrounds the recent unauthorized intelligence disclosures, we should not ignore the value of the U.S. intel community – including NSA – in combatting terrorism.  

Intelligence programs save lives.  They help disrupt terrorist cells abroad before they can strike at our closest allies, and they allowed the FBI’s Joint Terrorism Task Force and the NYPD to capture the New York City subway bomber before he could execute his plan.  The dedication of the men and women of our intel community, including at the NSA, is a significant reason we have enjoyed relative security since 9/11.  We cannot afford to relinquish this tool any more than we would sacrifice our military advantage; so, even as we take necessary steps to review our intelligence programs and ensure they are appropriately tailored and have the right level of policy oversight, we also need to preserve our capability to protect our nation.  We are committed to striking the right balance between securing Americans and our allies and the privacy concerns all people share. 

Law enforcement and the criminal justice community constitute the fourth pillar in our CT structure.  I witnessed the FBI and the Department of Justice transform from exclusively law enforcement agencies to vital and active elements of our national security structure.  From the National Security Division at Justice—which I was privileged to lead before coming to the White House—to the Department of Homeland Security and the National Counterterrorism Center, we have created institutions where professionals sit and work together to better share their expertise.  So the idea that we could ever return to a pre-9/11 approach to CT is not only wrong, we’ve made it downright impossible. 

A clear example of this is the capture at sea and the successful prosecution of Ahmed Warsame.  It’s a textbook case of how we draw on the strengths of each CT pillar and bring them together to deliver results.  Warsame was al-Shabaab’s liaison to AQAP in Yemen.  Our intelligence community identified and tracked him.  At the right time, while he was in transit between Yemen and Somalia, our military captured and held him for two months for interrogation, gaining a trove of new intelligence on two major al Qaeda affiliates.  Afterwards, he was Mirandized and indicted by a grand jury, but he chose to continue speaking with the FBI, providing further valuable intel in exchange for a plea deal.  Ultimately, he was charged and pleaded guilty.

And, it was intelligence, carefully gathered over a period of years, and fed to special operators, as well as close coordination with the FBI, that landed Abu Anas al-Libi in a New York courtroom last month. 

Finally, our strategy depends on diplomatic and civilian assistance for our partners.  Across the Middle East and North Africa, and in countries undergoing transition all around the world, our diplomats and development experts are working around the clock to help our partners better serve the needs and aspirations of their people.

Yemen offers perhaps the most striking example of how we have helped improve a partner’s CT capacity while supporting a political reform process aimed at making the government more responsive and accountable to its citizens.  Since 2009, we have invested nearly $400 million to train and equip the Yemeni military, including their specialized CT units.  A highly-effective Yemeni offensive last year helped drive AQAP out of communities and gave the Yemeni people the confidence to rise up. 

But just as important to our CT goals, the Yemenis are leading a historic national dialogue to chart a more just and democratic future for their country—an effort I discussed just yesterday in a conversation with President Hadi.  The United States has provided support to Yemen’s political transition, including preparations for the constitutional referendum, national elections, and ensuring that women, youth, and civil society are all active participants in the national dialogue.  At the same time, we are providing humanitarian assistance to relieve the growing crisis caused by the widespread lack of access to food and clean water.  And, looking toward a more stable and prosperous future for all the people of Yemen, the United States is investing to help spur greater economic growth over the long term. 

In the Horn of Africa, an international coalition of African partners is actively pushing back the threat of al-Shabaab.  The African Union Mission in Somalia, or AMISOM, is establishing the security conditions necessary for Somalia’s government to operate, with financial support and training assistance from the United States and our international partners.  But we have also invested heavily to encourage the new government to develop accountable and representative institutions so that Somalia can eventually become a peaceful nation, capable of protecting and policing itself.  As the famine we saw a few years ago recedes, we have shifted our focus.  We’re supporting activities that build stability, foster democracy, and boost economic growth.  And, we are working with the international community to build cooperation among Somali regions and clans and to bolster local support for the nation’s government and institutions.    

Responding to Future Threats

Now, despite our many successes, the unfortunate truth is that there will always be another threat.  Killing Osama bin Laden and degrading core al-Qaeda does not put an end to terrorism or our focus against it.   

Terrorists will continue to attack our diplomatic facilities, our businesses, and our citizens, and we know al-Qaeda core and its affiliates, like AQAP, remain determined to attack the homeland.  We also see the potential for direct threats to emerge from new directions, particularly from al Qaeda-linked groups in Syria, which are gaining strength in the midst of a protracted conflict between rebel forces and Assad’s regime.  So our counterterrorism strategy not only focuses on detecting and defeating threats, it seeks to bolster the resilience we show as a people.  That means that we recognize and accept the risks of being present and engaged around the world, even as we work to protect all those who represent our country abroad. 

It also means recognizing that homeland security is more than just taking your shoes off when you fly.  It’s about how we prevent, mitigate, respond to, and recover from emergencies, whether that’s terrorist attacks or natural hazards like hurricanes and floods or tornadoes.   

In Boston and New York, in West, Texas and Moore, Oklahoma, across the Jersey Shore and in communities all over this great nation, we have seen Americans come together to rebuild their lives after a tragedy.  Think about the neighbors who worked together to muck out their homes after Hurricane Sandy.  Remember the everyday citizens who became extraordinary heroes when the bombs went off in Boston—running into the smoke and confusion and fear to help.  The refusal to be terrorized; the readiness to rebuild—that’s resilience.  And that’s what we are working to build into every layer of our society. 

That’s why the final essential pillar of our counterterrorism architecture is also this country’s greatest asset:  our people, and the values we stand for.  Community connections are the bedrock of our resilience to terrorist threats.  And we rely on strong community engagement to prevent attacks before they can take place.  By working together, we can intervene with individuals a community identifies as in danger of radicalizing before they become a threat.  

Those in al-Qaeda and other extremist groups perpetuate a warped vision of the world where Muslims and the United States are locked in perpetual conflict, and where basic rights and liberties are not shared equally.  As we actively refute this ideology in public forums around the world and online, we also strive to project the power of our most deeply held values in word and deed.  Part of that effort depends upon turning the page on elements of the post-9/11 period, which is why we remain committed to closing the prison in Guantanamo Bay, which has become a drain on our resources and a polarizing symbol around the world.  

Conclusion

In this job, people often ask me what keeps me up at night.  As I’ve outlined today, there are many out there who wish to do us harm—around the world and here at home, as we saw last spring in Boston.  The Boston Marathon bombings happened within my first few weeks on the job.  It was the nightmare scenario, and it happened in my hometown.  It was a round-the-clock effort to track down the perpetrators and help the city of Boston regain its sense of security. 

Today—rather than what keeps me up—I’d like to end by telling you what helps me sleep, and that is my complete faith in the men and women who have dedicated their lives to this nation.  From the intel analyst sifting through data to find the critical clue, to the special operations sergeant risking his life to help one of our partner nations succeed, to the prosecutors and judges and cops who serve justice back home, they persevere; they excel.   

There is no such thing as certainty in counterterrorism work, and there is no such thing as 100 percent security.  Still, we make progress each and every day to undermine the conditions where terrorists can operate.  There are numerous silent victories.  We’ve built a robust counterterrorism architecture to meet the threats we face today, and with your help, the new threats we will face in the future. 

Thank you.

The White House

Office of the Vice President

Remarks to the Press by Vice President Joe Biden and President Ricardo Martinelli of Panama

Presidential Palace
Panama City, Panama

11:42 A.M. EST

PRESIDENT MARTINELLI:  (As interpreted.)  Thank you very much.  First of all, I would like to welcome Vice President Joseph Biden and his entire team, made up of senators, representatives and mayors from various cities in the United States, as well as their aides. 

This has been a very profitable meeting in which we have discussed a variety of subjects, among which is the subject of security -- regional security -- and the ongoing support that Panama and the United States contribute for hemispheric security with everything involving drug trafficking, terrorism, and other forms of trafficking.

Likewise we have discussed the expansion of the Canal and how significant and important it is for world commerce, as well as, very specially, for the East Coast of the United States.  It is imperative and necessary that the ports on the East Coast of the United States increase the dredging capability of their ports and go to at least 50 feet depth in order to take advantage of the new sizes of ships -- the post-Panamax ships that will be able to transit the Panama Canal with the expansion.  For that purpose, it’s necessary for the East Coast ports in the United States to increase their depth to 50 feet.  This will bring a number of benefits not only for Panama and for the world economy, but also for the enormous amount of jobs and other opportunities that will be created in an enormous number of ports in the United States.

As you well know, the Panamanian government and the Panama Canal have begun the expansion of the Canal, and this Canal expansion leads to a completion in 2015.  And likewise, we have discussed with Vice President Biden that already the United States and a number of other friendly countries must begin to study the possibility of Canal expansion, to do the appropriate studies so that when they’re done in a few years, what is called a fourth set of locks be completed, because as you well know, the world maritime community is continually innovating and increasing capabilities, and therefore, there is great potential for Panama to continue taking advantage of its position as a multimodal hub, which is very well complemented by what is happening in the ports along the East Coast of the United States.

We've also discussed the diplomatic and commercial relationship between Panama and the United States, and both governments will continue to work on the improvement of these relations and in order to increase world trade and hemispheric security.

Many thanks.

VICE PRESIDENT BIDEN:  Well, Mr. President, let me begin by saying it’s great to be with you again.  You’ve been a great friend to my country and you’ve been a good friend to me.  And I appreciate it very much.

Folks, we had a terrific conversation with the President and his Cabinet.  And my colleagues and I -- the mayors of some of the largest cities in America, as well as United States Senator Johnny Isakson from the great state of Georgia, and the gentlewoman, the Congresswoman from south Florida -- we had one of the best conversations that I've experienced, and I've been doing this a long time.

And I want to thank you, Mr. President, your administration, and the Panamanian people, for your friendship to the United States of America.  And again, I want to personally thank the Panamanian people for that friendship.

You know, modernizing the Canal, Mr. President, is an investment in your future, but it is also a consequential investment in the future of the United States of America.  It protects Panama’s unique place in the world economy as a new generation of massive container ships and tankers hits the high seas.  You're moving from the ability to accommodate a ship that's 106 feet wide to a ship that's 160 feet wide, doubling the commerce.  And it’s an incredible consequence to this global economy.

But the reason I traveled here -- with our Secretary of Transportation, Anthony Foxx; the Senator from Georgia, Senator Isakson; the Congresswoman from Florida, Debbie Wasserman- Shultz; the Atlanta Mayor -- the Mayor of Atlanta, Kasim Reed; the Mayor of Baltimore, Stephanie Rollins-Blake; and the Mayor of Philadelphia, Michael Nutter -- and your press may be asking, why am I mentioning each of their names.  I mention each of their names because they are in and they lead cities that have the potential to vastly expand the economic commerce, the jobs and the economy of their states and cities as a consequence of what the Panamanian people have done.

And it matters -- it matters a great deal to the American people.  It matters to our manufacturers.  It matters to our farmers, our Merchant Marine, and our longshoremen.  It matters a great deal, as you know, Mr. President, to businessmen that will enable American business to be more competitive.  People locate businesses and manufacturing facilities in places where they can quickly, cheaply, and responsibly get their product to market.  That only occurs if there is serious infrastructure to accommodate what the world economy is witnessing as a consequence of the Canal being widened, because when goods travel faster and cheaper, it increases commerce around the world. 

And it matters to the people those businesses will hire because this will create jobs -- not only jobs it's already created in Panama, but jobs in the United States of America and up and down the Americas.  The fact of the matter is these are not just ordinary jobs, these are good, decent jobs -- jobs you can raise a middle-class family on, jobs that you can care for your family. 

So that’s a long way of saying, Mr. President, we owe you and the people of Panama for continuing to have a forward-looking vision and not only strengthening your country, but quite frankly, strengthening the Hemisphere. 

It's also a reflection of a larger reality, Mr. President, that you and I have talked about in the past and again today, and that is the Americans -- the Americas, the Western Hemisphere, I say to all the people of Panama -- the Western Hemisphere is emerging as a region of opportunity.  In the mind of President Obama and me, there is no reason why the 20th century -- the 21st century will not be led by the Western Hemisphere as the center of gravity for the world economy.

Latin America, for the first time in our lifetime, has -- first time in history -- has 150 million people who are middle class, and strong -- for the first time.  For the first time in history you can look from Canada to the tip of Argentina and envision a hemisphere that is democratic, middle class, and secure -- and growing.  That has never occurred before in history.

The world's -- Latin America, particularly North America, is emerging as the energy center of gravity for the world.  It's shifting to the Western Hemisphere; from the sands of the Arabian Peninsula to the Western Hemisphere.  It will be the new center of gravity for energy production in the world.  We can now realistically envision and work toward, as I said, an Americas that are secure, middle class and democratic from the continent -- from Canada all the way to the tip of South America.

The question in my country is no longer what I believe Latin Americans are tired of hearing -- this notion of a benevolent America, the United States, what can we do for our brethren in the Hemisphere.  It's no longer that.  That’s not how President Obama and I look at it.  We look at it as what can we do together -- what can we do together.  And what you've done with the Canal is an example of the mutual contributions being made. 

This is a region -- the Hemisphere is a region that is growing and has unlimited potential.  And so it's what can we do together -- no longer -- as I said earlier, it's no longer these assertions of America's backyard.  This is the front yard.  This is a different world.  This is a different set of opportunities for all of us.  And that’s what President Martinelli and I spoke about today, and, I must admit, we've spoken about it in the past privately. 

We discussed the next steps forward in our economic partnership.  The United States supports Panama's long-term ambition to build an economy that rivals Singapore; one where there is fair competition, high standards, the rule of law, and transparent and open markets.  That is the future.  That will be the gold standard.  That’s the standard to which countries will repair, attract investment and jobs and growth.

These are the principles behind the U.S.-Panama Free Trade Agreement.  And in the years since it went in force, trade between the United States and Panama has already grown in one year by 18 percent. 

But there's much more work to be done.  We support Panama's effort to level the economic playing field, reduce corruption -- something every country has to contend with.  We want to work together to iron out the last unresolved issues to fully implement the trade agreement that we have made. 

And just as you connect the Atlantic and Pacific, Mr. President, Panama can be the economic bridge between the North and the South in a literal sense.  That’s the choice for Panamanians to make, not for the United States, but you can be that bridge.  The benefits of greater regional economic integration in connecting roads, energy grids, markets, they are considerable.  They're considerable not only for Panama but for the hemisphere.  As President Obama said in Costa Rica in May, if you and your neighbors choose this path, the United States will be there and help you get there. 

You know, we're ready right now to make it easier for personal travel to take place, make it easier for Panamanians to travel to the United States.  Today, I'm pleased to announce on behalf of President Obama that Panama will be the newest member of the U.S. Global Entry Program.  That means Panamanian citizens can be prescreened to travel faster through immigration ports in the United States of America.  Facilitating the flow of people is good for trade, it's good for tourism, and it's good for relationships between the countries.  It's a reflection of our friendship and our trust in Panama and the Panamanian people.  And we're honored that President Martinelli will be the first Panamanian citizen to take part in this.

And I want to say to your Minister of Security, Mr. Mulino, the great work that Panama has done on the security side of the equation. 

As we streamline the travel and trade, we're also working together to stop illegal trafficking.  Panama has interdicted 175 metric tons of cocaine.  Cooperation between our law enforcement agencies is excellent and been at a peak that hasn't existed before.  And Panama is rising and in some cases exceeding its responsibilities not only to us, but to the region. 

And so last July, a vessel traveling through the Panama Canal from Cuba to North Korea claimed it was carrying sugar.  Well, it was a sweet cargo, but it wasn't sugar.  It wasn't sugar.  And Panama did something we haven't come to expect everywhere in the world -- it stepped up.  It stepped up where others might have stepped back.  We think it's a violation of U.S. sanctions [sic].  But, nonetheless, Panama stepped up.  You found and confiscated weapons heading from Cuba to North Korea. 

The United States is thankful for your taking on that international responsibility.  And you made a significant contribution for real to global security, not just U.S. security.  We are pretty well capable of handling our own security.  But you contributed to global security.  That is what responsible nations do and that's what you have done.

And as a member of the Organization of American States, we also made a collective commitment -- you and I and the Organization of American States -- to hold free and fair elections.  President Martinelli reaffirmed his commitment to that today. 

It's larger than any one of us.  Each democratic success story, each democratic election stacked upon one another, strengthens the entire hemisphere.  That's how the hemisphere is being built.  Panama has an opportunity to do just that again when you go to the polls in 2014. 

And I look forward, as I've told the President, today, after leaving here and going to my embassy, and we're going to go to the Canal, I'm also going to meet with the respective presidential candidates in the 2014 election. 

And, finally, I updated President Martinelli and his colleagues in our efforts to achieve comprehensive immigration reform.  It is the priority for the President and me now.  We need -- we need -- to update and make more rational our immigration policy in the United States of America.  It's a matter of simple justice and respect.  Respect and dignity needs to be brought to the 11 million undocumented men, women and children, allowing them to come out of the shadows.  They are not only Hispanic.  They represent every part of the world.  They are Asian.  They are Irish.  They are Russian.  They are African.  But they deserve to be treated with dignity. 

In my experience in the family I come from, you measure a man or woman in how they feel about you and how they treat the people who are like you.  This is a matter -- this is a matter of respect.  This is a matter of hemispheric respect, in my view.

And so, when we respect your countrymen on our soil, I hope that sends the message as to how we feel -- that we respect you and all folks in the hemisphere.  And we do.  But it's also a matter, as you pointed out in your own immigration policy here, Mr. President, it's also a matter of just naked self-interest -- naked self-interest. 

Our Congressional Budget Office, sort of the gold standard of what constitutes economic growth -- our Congressional Budget Office recently estimated that the comprehensive immigration reform the President and I are pushing will grow the U.S. economy by $1.4 trillion over the next decade and a half -- $1.4 trillion. 

I was saying that recently -- I've traveled about 800,000 miles since being Vice President.  I was recently in Singapore.  And if I can say, I told the President -- and this is not part of my formal remarks -- but I met with one of the wisest men that most leaders around the world have sought out -- Lee Kuan Yew, a former President of Singapore.  And I sat with him.  And he is 92 years old, and his health is somewhat frail, but his mind is, as my mother would say, sharp as a tack.  I don't know how you translate that into Spanish.  (Laughter.)  

But I sat with him and I said, “Mr. President, what is China doing now?”  He said, the Chinese are in America, “The United States looking for that black box that is buried.”  And I'm thinking black box?  What does he mean by that?  It's like the flight recorder data in an aircraft.  I said, black box?  He said, yes.  He said, “That secret that allows the United States to be the only country in the world that constantly is able to remake itself, to reinvent itself.” 

And, I said, oh, Mr. President, I can tell you what's in that black box.  It's a constant stream of immigration.  It's the constant refurbishing of the energy of America by new cultures, new language, new people. 

And, I said the second thing in that black box is every America has stamped in their DNA, whether they are immigrants or they are born there, that they have -- every young student is encouraged to shed the notion of respect for orthodoxy.  The only way new things happen is when orthodoxy is put aside.  That's the secret of the United States of America.  And Panama and the rest of this hemisphere is a big part of the secret of our success.

So I came to say thank you, Mr. President -- thank you, thank the Panamanian people -- and I look forward to this relationship continuing to grow and prosper.  And as a consequence of what you've done at the Canal, we have the possibility of expanding our economy by hundreds of billions of dollars over the near term. 

So, thank you, Mr. President.  And I look forward to seeing you again.  (Applause.)  

END
12:03 P.M. EST

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by Vice President Joe Biden at the Panama Canal

Panama Canal, Panama

4:15 P.M. EST

VICE PRESIDENT BIDEN:  Mr. President, distinguished guests, and to the 9,500 workers who are expanding this Canal, on behalf of the United States of America, thank you.  Thank you for what you're doing.

I've been traveling up and down the East Coast of the United States and into the heart of the Midwest of our country and down to the Gulf of Mexico, telling the American people that something big is happening here in Panama that will have a profound effect on the economy of the United States of America.  By the widening and deepening of the Panama Canal, you're making not only a major investment, Mr. President, in your company's future -- your country's future, but in my country's future.  You're providing a service not only to the Panamanian people but the United States, the hemisphere and the entire world. 

I came here today from the Port of Houston in the state of Texas.  In 1956, the world's first container ship, the Ideal X, sailed into the Port of Houston.  Instead of sacks and crates and boxes carried neatly in the hull of the ship, on top of that ship were stacked containers on its deck.  In an instant, the shipping costs for a ton of cargo were reduced by 97 percent.  It changed global commerce. 

What you're doing here today, and what my colleagues and I are witnessing, is going to change global commerce.  It's shifting once again.  A new generation of massive vessels, known as post-Panamax ships, are able to carry twice or even three times as many containers as what has come before.  These ships are wider, longer, and their drafts are deeper.

I just looked at "the old Canal."  It can accommodate a 106-foot-wide ship.  The Canal being built here will accommodate 160-foot-wide ships.  The arrival of these new ships presents an opportunity for countries to transport goods more cheaply than ever before.  But it's also a challenge for all of us in the rest of the world to modernize to accommodate the infrastructure that you're building here, Mr. President.

People use the phrase all the time, "it's a global economy."  I'm not sure they fully understand that exactly, it is a global economy.  Seventy-five percent of all the commerce in the world as I speak is floating somewhere in the ocean as I speak, containing 75 percent of the world's commerce.  And what you're doing here in Panama is a next level -- is taking commerce to a brand-new level. 

That’s exactly what Panama is doing right now.  The Canal has two lanes that cannot handle these post-Panamax ships -- but not for long.  By the end of 2015, these massive new locks will open and be able to accommodate ships with 50-foot drafts, not 39.5; 1,200-feet long, not 965-feet long; 160-feet wide, not 106-feet wide.  The Panama Canal Authority estimates that it will double the amount of cargo -- double the amount of cargo -- that passes through this Canal now by the year 2015. 

And I'm here with my colleagues -- the Mayor of Atlanta, the Mayor of Baltimore, the Mayor of Philadelphia, and, ladies and gentlemen, the Senator from the state of a little old port called Savannah in the state of Georgia, and the Mayor from that state, and our Secretary of Transportation -- because it affects -- it will affect drastically, what's happening here, their communities, their people.  And it's going to require us to invest in 21st infrastructure like you're doing.

And I'm here because I believe that the cutting-edge Panama Canal and the investments that it inspires and the trade that it will make possible can be part of the story of the economic continued revival of the United States of America and the hemisphere. 

It's no secret that in 2008, the United States and the world went through a heck of a difficult time -- the greatest recession in our history short of a depression.  But we fought our way back.  U.S. businesses have created 7.8 million new jobs in the last 44 months.  Manufacturing is coming back to the United States.  We've created 500,000 new manufacturing jobs.  Our auto manufacturers have created an additional 325,000 jobs.  We now produce more natural gas than any country on Earth.  And for the first time, we've imported less oil than we have consumed -- than we produce in the United States. 

The reason I bother to say this is that the next phase here, the next phase is to take advantage of what this new commerce will do.  We know in America these representatives, Democrat and Republican, know in my home state, my states, they understand that manufacturers locate where they can cheaply, efficiently and economically get their cargo to a worldwide market. 

We still have a way to go in the United States, but we've made significant progress.  Our companies are competing, exporting to every country, every corner of the world.  And we're once again an engine of economic growth with the potential to create a next generation of good-paying jobs, as the jobs you're providing here are, Mr. President.

You've weathered that worldwide recession in part because of this bold commitment you and your people have made.  And we're ready for the new Panama Canal to contribute to our economic renewal as well.  And your project is profoundly in the interest of my country.  Two-thirds of everything that passes through the Panama Canal is either coming from or going to the United States of America.  So when the Canal doubles its capacity, the United States has a potential to expand exports at a considerably lower cost and considerably higher volume. 

So if we make the right investments at home, we will allow the United States ports to handle larger ships coming through this modernized Canal.  When exports can carry two to three times more in each container ship, that saves business.  That saves money.  That saves shipping costs.  That saves fuel.  And it makes manufacturers and farmers in America more competitive. 

For example, one-third of the U.S. grain and soybean exports travel through your canal.  By one estimate, each bushel will be about 35 percent -- 35 cents cheaper because of this Canal, making American farmers even more competitive. 

Building up our ports to handle the increased cargo will also create jobs for longshoreman, construction workers, engineers and others, dredging ports, widening docks, building new storage, also having intermodal changes in our railroads, in our Interstate Highway System. 

So I'm here with a simple, Mr. President, but heartfelt message to the people of Panama:  Thank you.  Thank you for having the courage to embark on this significant adventure here.

After telling so many others about the new and improved Panama Canal that's emerging, I decided, and my colleagues, that we've got to come down and see it for ourselves.  Instead of preaching to the choir, we wanted to be with the choir.  We wanted to make sure we saw it.  And I brought with me our Secretary of Transportation, Anthony Foxx; Georgia Senator -- one of the leading members of the United States Senate -- Johnny Isakson, representing the Port of Savannah, which, I might add, is responsible for more than $67 billion in economic activity and supports 350,000 full-time and part-time jobs across the state of Georgia, including in the city of Atlanta, it's largest city. 

The Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed is here with me today as well, because it affects the standard of living in his city.  Florida Congresswoman Debbie Wasserman-Schultz, she represents ports bringing more than 400,000 jobs to Floridians.  Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, where her port sends $22 billion in U.S. goods around the world with the label "Made In America" on them.  And Mayor Michael Nutter of my adopted hometown -- more than 2 million tons a year of containerized cargo pass through the Port of Philadelphia.  All of that, all of them have the ability to profoundly expand employment and income for their states. 

So, Mr. President, you may be surprised to learn that you have fans far afield.  You found out today, in Baltimore, Maryland; and Atlanta, Georgia; and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; in South Florida.  Today -- I hope I don’t get you in trouble, Mr. President, but today, as we left our bilateral meeting, we then had an expanded meeting with my colleagues.  And I turned around as we were leaving and I wondered where the President was -- the President was surrounded by each of my colleagues bidding for him -- please come to Philadelphia, please come to Baltimore, please come to Atlanta.  (Laughter.)  I’m serious.

So I just want to say to the people of Panama, this is a very important thing for the United States.  This new and improved Canal will also benefit Panama, to state the obvious, bringing an economic windfall in the form of greater revenue.  It will help Panama remain an indispensable part of the global economy. 

And as the energy production throughout the Americas grows, Panama is going to play a critical role in bridging energy supplies in the Atlantic with a growing demand in the Pacific.  This is good business.  This is good for Panama.  And it’s clear that the world of opportunity is available to those willing to make the necessary investments to compete in the 21st century. 

Panama is making that investment, and the United States has to do the same now.  We’re ready.  When the United States passed what we call in the States the Recovery Act, it included $48 billion in new infrastructure -- the largest public works project in America since the construction of the Interstate Highway System.  Each port, though, has different needs.  There are different places.  Bridges need to be made higher.  Wharfs need to be made longer.  Berths need to be made wider.  Water needs to be dredged.  Communities across our country are working to address these problems, and through federal grants, we’re working to modernize state and public funding. 

That $48 billion the federal government supplied generated well over $150 billion in private investment and state investment.  The $10 billion [sic] we invested in one of the ports generated in that port another $80 million. 

So, folks, look, this is about the totality of how our infrastructure connects.  As Secretary Foxx says, it’s about the first mile and the last mile of infrastructure that gets American exports from the factory floor to the decks of ships.  For example, it’s about how a rail line in Ohio connects shipping to the Port of Baltimore.  That’s why we put in $50 million in investment and it generated multifold in that in terms of being able to have access to the ports.

In conclusion, Mr. President, let me say what I’ve said to you privately on other occasions and I say publicly:  We thank the people of Panama.  And I want you to know, speaking for President Obama and myself, the day is long passed when America looks out and saw a backyard.  This is no backyard.  This is the yard -- this is the front yard.  The hemisphere is growing. 

For the first time in history, you can picture from Canada to the tip of Argentina a hemisphere that is democratic, middle-class, secure, as the leading engine of economic growth in the world in the 21st century.  And Panama will play a critical part in that.

So, Mr. President, it’s not what we can do for you -- what you’re doing for us and what we can do with you.  The historic expansion of the Canal that is underway shows how strong Panama is and the pure self-interest of the United States of America.  You’re a powerful symbol of Panama’s success, Mr. President, and it’s a reminder that our futures, the United States and Panama and this hemisphere, are inextricably linked. 

Your work on this Canal strengthens my country.  We owe you.  We thank you.  May God bless you all.  And may God protect our troops.  Thank you all very much.  (Applause.)      

END               

4:35 P.M. EST