The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Presidential Nominations Sent to the Senate

NOMINATIONS SENT TO THE SENATE:

Colin Stirling Bruce, of Illinois, to be United States District Judge for the Central District of Illinois, vice Michael P. McCuskey, retiring.

Sara Lee Ellis, of Illinois, to be United States District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois, vice Joan B. Gottschall, retired.

Andrea R. Wood, of Illinois, to be United States District Judge for the Northern District of Illinois, vice William J. Hibbler, deceased.

Here's What President Obama Told the Class of 2013 at The Ohio State University

President Barack Obama delivers the commencement address during The Ohio State University (May 5, 2013)

President Barack Obama delivers the commencement address during The Ohio State University commencement at Ohio Stadium in Columbus, Ohio, May 5, 2013. (Official White House Photo by Pete Souza)

The Ohio State University is an institution that dedicates itself to “Education for Citizenship” -- the Buckeye motto emblazoned on the school seal.

So when President Obama spoke to the Class of 2013 at the school's graduation, citizenship was his theme.

"As citizens, we understand that it’s not about what America can do for us," he said. "It’s about what can be done by us, together, through the hard and frustrating but absolutely necessary work of self-government. And, Class of 2013, you have to be involved in that process."

The President made a pitch for civic connection -- for participation in public life, for engagement in national debates, for community service. He pointed to those who stand up in moments of crisis -- running toward the damage inflicted by the bombs in Boston to care for survivors, helping neighbors dig out from Hurricane Sandy last fall -- as examples.

"We've seen courage and compassion, a sense of civic duty, and a recognition we are not a collection of strangers; we are bound to one another by a set of ideals and laws and commitments, and a deep devotion to this country that we love," he said. "And that's what citizenship is."

Above all, he urged survivors to break through the cycle of cynicism that too often cripples progress in this country.

"Only you can make sure the democracy you inherit is as good as we know it can be," President Obama told the graduates. "But it requires your dedicated, and informed, and engaged citizenship. And that citizenship is a harder, higher road to take, but it leads to a better place."

Read the full remarks. Or watch the video:

Related Topics: Inside the White House, Ohio

President Obama Speaks at The Ohio State University Commencement Ceremony

May 05, 2013 | 26:18 | Public Domain

President Obama delivers the commencement address at The Ohio State University.

Download mp4 (970MB) | mp3 (63MB)

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks by the President at The Ohio State University Commencement

Ohio Stadium
Columbus, Ohio

1:00 P.M. EDT

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you.  (Applause.)  Hello, Buckeyes!  O-H! 

AUDIENCE:  I-O!

THE PRESIDENT:  O-H!

AUDIENCE:  I-O!

THE PRESIDENT:  O-H!

AUDIENCE:  I-O!  

THE PRESIDENT:  Well, thank you so much.  Everybody, please be seated.  Thank you, Dr. Gee, for the wonderful introduction.  I suspect the good President may have edited out some other words that were used to describe me.  (Laughter.)  I appreciate that.  But I'm going to let Michelle know of all the good comments.

To the Board of Trustees; Congresswoman Beatty; Mayor Coleman; and all of you who make up The Ohio State University for allowing me to join you -- it is an incredible honor.   

And most of all, congratulations, Class of 2013!  (Applause.)  And of course, congratulations to all the parents, and family, and friends and faculty here in the Horseshoe -- this is your day as well.  (Applause.)  I've been told to ask everybody, though, please be careful with the turf.  Coach Meyer has big plans for this fall.  (Laughter.) 

I very much appreciate the President’s introduction.  I will not be singing today.  (Laughter.)

AUDIENCE:  Aww -- (laughter.)

THE PRESIDENT:  It is true that I did speak at that certain university up north a few years ago.  But, to be fair, you did let President Ford speak here once -- and he played football for Michigan!  (Laughter.)  So everybody can get some redemption. 

In my defense, this is my fifth visit to campus in the past year or so.  (Applause.)  One time, I stopped at Sloppy’s to grab some lunch.  Many of you -- Sloopy’s -- I know.  (Laughter.)  It’s Sunday and I'm coming off a foreign trip.  (Laughter.)  Anyway, so I'm at Sloopy’s and many of you were still eating breakfast.  At 11:30 a.m.  (Laughter.)  On a Tuesday.  (Laughter.)  So, to the Class of 2013, I will offer my first piece of advice:  Enjoy it while you can.  (Laughter.)  Soon, you will not get to wake up and have breakfast at 11:30 a.m. on Tuesday.  (Laughter.)  And once you have children, it gets even earlier.  (Laughter.) 

But, Class of 2013, your path to this moment has wound you through years of breathtaking change.  You were born as freedom forced its way through a wall in Berlin, tore down an Iron Curtain across Europe.  You were educated in an era of instant information that put the world’s accumulated knowledge at your fingertips.  And you came of age as terror touched our shores; and an historic recession spread across the nation; and a new generation signed up to go to war. 

So you’ve been tested and you’ve been tempered by events that your parents and I never imagined we’d see when we sat where you sit.  And yet, despite all this, or perhaps because of it, yours has become a generation possessed with that most American of ideas -- that people who love their country can change it for the better.  For all the turmoil, for all the times you’ve been let down, or frustrated at the hand that you’ve been dealt, what I have seen -- what we have witnessed from your generation -- is that perennial, quintessentially American value of optimism; altruism; empathy; tolerance; a sense of community; a sense of service -- all of which makes me optimistic for our future.

Consider that today, 50 ROTC cadets in your graduating class will become commissioned officers in the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines.  (Applause.)  A hundred and thirty of your fellow graduates have already served -- some in combat, some on multiple deployments.  (Applause.)  Of the 98 veterans earning bachelor’s degrees today, 20 are graduating with honors, and at least one kept serving his fellow veterans when he came home by starting up a campus organization called Vets4Vets.  And as your Commander-in-Chief, I could not be prouder of all of you.  (Applause.)

Consider that graduates of this university serve their country through the Peace Corps, and educate our children through established programs like Teach for America, startups like Blue Engine, often earning little pay for making the biggest impact.  Some of you have already launched startup companies of your own. And I suspect that those of you who pursue more education, or climb the corporate ladder, or enter the arts or science or journalism, you will still choose a cause that you care about in your life and will fight like heck to realize your vision. 

There is a word for this.  It’s citizenship.  And we don’t always talk about this idea much these days -- citizenship -- let alone celebrate it.  Sometimes, we see it as a virtue from another time, a distant past, one that’s slipping from a society that celebrates individual ambition above all else; a society awash in instant technology that empowers us to leverage our skills and talents like never before, but just as easily allows us to retreat from the world.  And the result is that we sometimes forget the larger bonds we share as one American family.

But it’s out there, all the time, every day -- especially when we need it most.  Just look at the past year.  When a hurricane struck our mightiest city, and a factory exploded in a small town in Texas, we saw citizenship.  When bombs went off in Boston, and when a malevolent spree of gunfire visited a movie theater, a temple, an Ohio high school, a 1st grade classroom in Connecticut, we saw citizenship.  In the aftermath of darkest tragedy, we have seen the American spirit at its brightest. 

We’ve seen the petty divisions of color and class and creed replaced by a united urge to help each other.  We’ve seen courage and compassion, a sense of civic duty, and a recognition we are not a collection of strangers; we are bound to one another by a set of ideals and laws and commitments, and a deep devotion to this country that we love. 

And that's what citizenship is.  It’s at the heart of our founding -- that as Americans, we are blessed with God-given talents and inalienable rights, but with those rights come responsibilities -- to ourselves, and to one another, and to future generations.  (Applause.)

Now, if we’re being honest with ourselves, as you’ve studied and worked and served to become good citizens, the fact is that all too often the institutions that give structure to our society have, at times, betrayed your trust.  In the run-up to the financial crisis, too many on Wall Street forgot that their obligations don’t end with what’s happening with their shares. In entertainment and in the media, ratings and shock value often trump news and storytelling. 

In Washington -- well, this is a joyous occasion, so let me put it charitably -- (laughter) -- I think it’s fair to say our democracy isn’t working as well as we know it can.  It could do better.  (Applause.)  And so those of us fortunate enough to serve in these institutions owe it to you to do better every single day.

And I’ve been thinking a lot lately about how we can keep this idea of citizenship in its fullest sense alive at the national level -- not just on Election Day, not just in times of tragedy, but all the days in between.  And perhaps because I spend a lot of time in Washington, I’m obsessed with this issue because that sense of citizenship is so sorely needed there.  And I think of what your generation’s traits -- compassion and energy, and a sense of selflessness -- might mean for a democracy that must adapt more quickly to keep up with the speed of technological and demographic, and wrenching economic change.

I think about how we might perpetuate this notion of citizenship in a way that another politician from my home state of Illinois, Adlai Stevenson, once described patriotism not as “short, frenzied outbursts of emotion, but the tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime.”  That’s what patriotism is.  That’s what citizenship is.  (Applause.)

Now, I don’t pretend to have all the answers.  I’m not going to offer some grand theory on a beautiful day like this -- you guys all have celebrating to do.  I’m not going to get partisan, either, because that’s not what citizenship is about.  In fact, I’m asking the same thing of you that President Bush did when he spoke at this commencement in 2002:  “America needs more than taxpayers, spectators, and occasional voters,” he said. “America needs full-time citizens.”  (Applause.)  And as graduates from a university whose motto is “Education for Citizenship,” I know all of you get that this is what you’ve signed up for.  It’s what your country expects of you. 

So briefly, I’ll ask for two things from the Class of 2013: to participate, and to persevere.  After all, your democracy does not function without your active participation.  At a bare minimum, that means voting, eagerly and often -- not having somebody drag you to it at 11:30 a.m. when you’re having breakfast.  (Laughter.)  It means knowing who’s been elected to make decisions on your behalf, and what they believe in, and whether or not they delivered on what they said they would.  And if they don’t represent you the way you want, or conduct themselves the way you expect, if they put special interests above your own, you’ve got to let them know that’s not okay.  And if they let you down often enough, there’s a built-in day in November where you can really let them know it’s not okay.  (Applause.)

But participation, your civic duty, is more than just voting.  You don’t have to run for office yourself -- but I hope many of you do, at all levels, because our democracy needs you.  And I promise you, it will give you a tough skin.  I know a little bit about this.  (Laughter.)  President Wilson once said, “If you want to make enemies, try to change something.”

And that’s precisely what the Founders left us -- the power, each of us, to adapt to changing times.  They left us the keys to a system of self-government, the tools to do big things and important things together that we could not possibly do alone -- to stretch railroads and electricity and a highway system across a sprawling continent.  To educate our people with a system of public schools and land-grant colleges, including The Ohio State University.  To care for the sick and the vulnerable, and provide a basic level of protection from falling into abject poverty in the wealthiest nation on Earth.  (Applause.)  To conquer fascism and disease; to visit the Moon and Mars; to gradually secure our God-given rights for all of our citizens, regardless of who they are, or what they look like, or who they love.  (Applause.)  

We, the people, chose to do these things together -- because we know this country cannot accomplish great things if we pursue nothing greater than our own individual ambition. 

Unfortunately, you’ve grown up hearing voices that incessantly warn of government as nothing more than some separate, sinister entity that’s at the root of all our problems; some of these same voices also doing their best to gum up the works.  They’ll warn that tyranny is always lurking just around the corner.  You should reject these voices.  Because what they suggest is that our brave and creative and unique experiment in self-rule is somehow just a sham with which we can’t be trusted.

We have never been a people who place all of our faith in government to solve our problems; we shouldn’t want to.  But we don’t think the government is the source of all our problems, either.  Because we understand that this democracy is ours.  And as citizens, we understand that it’s not about what America can do for us; it’s about what can be done by us, together, through the hard and frustrating but absolutely necessary work of self-government.  (Applause.)  And, Class of 2013, you have to be involved in that process.  (Applause.)  

The founders trusted us with this awesome authority.  We should trust ourselves with it, too.  Because when we don’t, when we turn away and get discouraged and cynical, and abdicate that authority, we grant our silent consent to someone who will gladly claim it.  That’s how we end up with lobbyists who set the agenda; and policies detached from what middle-class families face every day; the well-connected who publicly demand that Washington stay out of their business -- and then whisper in government’s ear for special treatment that you don’t get. 

That’s how a small minority of lawmakers get cover to defeat something the vast majority of their constituents want.  That’s how our political system gets consumed by small things when we are a people called to do great things -- like rebuild a middle class, and reverse the rise of inequality, and repair the deteriorating climate that threatens everything we plan to leave for our kids and our grandkids.

Class of 2013, only you can ultimately break that cycle.  Only you can make sure the democracy you inherit is as good as we know it can be.  But it requires your dedicated, and informed, and engaged citizenship.  And that citizenship is a harder, higher road to take, but it leads to a better place.  It’s how we built this country -- together. 

It’s the question that President Kennedy posed to the nation at his inauguration.  It’s the dream that Dr. King invoked.  It does not promise easy success or immediate progress -- but it has led to success, and it has led to progress.  And it has to continue with you. 

Which brings me to the second thing I ask of all of you -- I ask that you persevere.  Whether you start a business, or run for office, or devote yourself to alleviating poverty or hunger, please remember that nothing worth doing happens overnight.  A British inventor named Dyson went through more than 5,000 prototypes before getting that first really fancy vacuum cleaner just right.  We remember Michael Jordan’s six championships; we don't remember his nearly 15,000 missed shots.  As for me, I lost my first race for Congress, and look at me now -- I’m an honorary graduate of The Ohio State University.  (Applause.)

The point is, if you are living your life to the fullest, you will fail, you will stumble, you will screw up, you will fall down.  But it will make you stronger, and you’ll get it right the next time, or the time after that, or the time after that.  And that is not only true for your personal pursuits, but it’s also true for the broader causes that you believe in as well. 

So you can't give up your passion if things don't work right away.  You can't lose heart, or grow cynical if there are twists and turns on your journey.  The cynics may be the loudest voices -- but I promise you, they will accomplish the least.  It’s those folks who stay at it, those who do the long, hard, committed work of change that gradually push this country in the right direction, and make the most lasting difference.

So whenever you feel that creeping cynicism, whenever you hear those voices saying you can’t do it, you can't make a difference, whenever somebody tells you to set your sights lower -- the trajectory of this great nation should give you hope.  What generations have done before you should give you hope.  Because it was young people just like you who marched and mobilized and stood up and sat in to secure women’s rights, and voting rights, and workers’ rights, and gay rights -- often at incredible odds, often at great danger, often over the course of years, sometimes over the tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime -- and they never got acknowledged for it, but they made a difference.  (Applause.)  

And even if their rights were already secured, there were those who fought to secure those same rights and opportunities for others.  And that should give you some hope. 

Where we’re going should give you hope.  Because while things are still hard for a lot of people, you have every reason to believe that your future is bright.  You’re graduating into an economy and a job market that is steadily healing.  The once-dying American auto industry is on pace for its strongest performance in 20 years -- something that means everything to many communities in Ohio and across the Midwest.  Huge strides in domestic energy, driven in part by research at universities like this one, have us on track to secure our own energy future.  Incredible advances in information and technology spurred largely by the risk-takers of your generation have the potential to change the way we do almost everything.

There is not another country on Earth that would not gladly change places with the United States of America.  And that will be true for your generation just as it was true for previous generations. 

So you’ve got a lot to look forward to, but if there’s one certainty about the decade ahead, it’s that things will be uncertain.  Change will be a constant, just as it has been throughout our history.  And, yes, we still face many important challenges.  Some will require technological breakthroughs or new policy insights.  But more than anything, what we will need is political will -- to harness the ingenuity of your generation, and encourage and inspire the hard work of dedicated citizens.  To repair the middle class, to give more families a fair shake, to reject a country in which only a lucky few prosper because that’s antithetical to our ideals and our democracy -- all of this is going to happen if you are involved, because it takes dogged determination -- the dogged determination of our citizens.

To educate more children at a younger age, and to reform our high schools for a new time, and to give more young people the chance to earn the kind of education that you did at The Ohio State University, and to make it more affordable so young people don’t leave with a mountain of debt -- that will take the care and concern of citizens like you.  (Applause.)

To build better roads and airports and faster Internet, and to advance the kinds of basic research and technology that’s always kept America ahead of everybody else -- that will take the grit and fortitude of citizens.

To confront the threat of climate change before it’s too late -- that requires the idealism and the initiative of citizens.

To protect more of our kids from the horrors of gun violence -- that requires the unwavering passion, the untiring resolve of citizens.  (Applause.)  It will require you.

Fifty years ago, President Kennedy told the class of 1963 that “our problems are manmade -- therefore, they can be solved by man.  And man can be as big as he wants.”  We’re blessed to live in the greatest nation on Earth.  But we can always be greater.  We can always aspire to something more.  That doesn’t depend on who you elect to office.  It depends on you, as citizens, how big you want us to be, how badly you want to see these changes for the better.

And look at all that America has already accomplished.  Look at how big we’ve been.  I dare you, Class of 2013, to do better. I dare you to dream bigger.

And from what I’ve seen of your generation, I'm confident that you will.  And so I wish you courage, and compassion, and all the strength that you will need for that tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime. 

Thank you.  God bless you, and God bless these United States of America.  (Applause.)

END  
1:26 P.M. EDT

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Gaggle by Josh Earnest en route Columbus, OH

Aboard Air Force One
En Route Columbus, Ohio

10:29 A.M. EDT

MR. EARNEST:  Good Sunday morning, everybody.  Happy Cinco de Mayo, and welcome aboard Air Force One for the trip to The Ohio State University, where the President will deliver the commencement address at ceremonies honoring the class of 2013. 

You should have embargoed remarks in your in-box, but I will note in advance that you can look for the President to challenge the graduates to use their education to be engaged, active participants in American democracy.  The authority of our system comes not just from elected leaders, but from active citizens.  In our country’s history, we've accomplished great things and brought about tremendous changes that even our Founders couldn't have envisioned because of the active engagement of the American people.  The President will note that role of engaged citizens has never been more important than ensuring a strong system of American government that reflects the interests and will of our people. 

So it should be an entertaining speech.  And with that we'll take a few questions.

Q    Josh, Israel is sharply escalating its role in the civil war in Syria with a new round of attacks, strikes there last night.  How concerned is the U.S. that this situation could devolve into more of a regional thing that embroils Israel and other countries?

MR. EARNEST:  Let me start by saying that we're horrified by the reports that more than 100 people were executed on May 2, in al-Bayda, reportedly by regime forces, including the Shabiha. Those responsible for serious violations of international humanitarian law and serious violations and abuses of human rights law must be held accountable.  As Bashar al-Assad continues to cling to power, we will not lose sight of the men, women and children who are being killed by his regime.

I wanted to get that out of the way first.  In terms of the reports that you're citing overnight, I don't have any comment on those reports.  I'm not in a position -- while we've seen those reports, I'm not in a position to offer you any confirmation of them. 

But you did hear the President talk to Telemundo in an interview yesterday about the reports from Thursday night about actions taken by the Israeli government.  The President didn’t comment on those reports either.  The President did note, however, that the Israelis are justifiably concerned about the threat posed by Hezbollah obtaining these advanced weapon systems.  And the President many times has talked about his view that Israel, as a sovereign government, has the right to take the actions they feel are necessary to protect their people.

But in terms of the overnight reports, I don't have anything specific for you. 

Q    Josh, seven American troops were killed yesterday in Afghanistan.  Has the President been in contact with commanders there since this happened?  And is the President comfortable with these CIA payments that are going -- that President Karzai said yesterday are going to continue?

MR. EARNEST:  The thoughts and prayers of the President and First Lady and everybody in the country are with the families of those who were lost -- the servicemen who were lost in Afghanistan.  There clearly is -- it’s a reminder once again, as if we needed a reminder, of the very serious effort and risk that American servicemen are taking to protect our interests in Afghanistan.  And that's something that occurs 24 hours a day, seven days a week.  And like I said, these reports underscore the risks that they face and the danger they put themselves in to protect our interests there.

In terms of the reports about the CIA payments, I don't have anything for you on that.  I'd refer you to the CIA.

Q    Is the President comfortable with them?

MR. EARNEST:  I'm not in a position to confirm any of those reports.  I'd refer you to the CIA.

Q    -- has the President had with any world leaders over the events of the past few days in Syria?

MR. EARNEST:  Well, the President has been traveling through Mexico and Central America over the last three or four days.  I don't have any specific calls to read out to you, but the President, as he took the trip, was joined by a number of senior members of his national security team -- National Security Advisor Donilon was with him; Deputy National Security Advisor Rhodes traveled with him.  So the President was kept up to date on these reports even as he was traveling.  But in terms of specific conversations that he had with world leaders, I don't have anything to read out to you at this point.

Q    Josh, is the President concerned that the civil war in Syria is being used as a cover for groups like Hezbollah to transfer weapons?

MR. EARNEST:  Well, we have seen violence in Syria that has gotten the attention of the international community.  The terrible use of weapons by the Assad regime against its own people is deplorable.  It is something that the international community is united to trying to end the bloodshed there.  It’s the view of the United States and many people around the world that a democratic transition in Syria cannot take place with Assad there, so Assad must leave power.

We've also talked about the threat, the destabilizing threat that this conflict poses to the region.  And it certainly is one of the many reasons it’s gotten so much attention that it has, and it’s one of the reasons that this is a top national security priority of this administration. 

But in terms of the motives of people, I can't shed any light on that.  The President has talked about his concern that there might be some extremist elements who would take advantage of the chaos and the instability to lay the groundwork for other acts of violence.  So the President has acknowledged that threat, and it’s certainly one of the many reasons that the United States is working with our international partners to try to find a way to bring this bloodshed to an end and ensure a transition to a government in Syria that actually reflects the will of the Syrian people.

Q    What’s the expectation within the administration on how much information you guys have, should Israel take action, beforehand?  Is there an expectation that you guys are being looped in before they would have an attack?

MR. EARNEST:  Well, I can tell you that the United States, and this administration, in particular, is in very close contact and is closely coordinating with the Israeli government on a range of issues, including important national security priorities.  So there are conversations and communications that are happening all the time between senior members of this administration and their counterparts in Israel. 

But in terms of the details of those conversations, I'm obviously not in a position to read those out.  But the close coordination between the Obama administration and the United States of America is ongoing with the Israeli government.

Q    You said that the United States believes Israel has a right to defend itself.  The Syrian government is calling these strikes a flagrant violation of Israel’s international obligations and all that.  So I just want to be clear.  Do you think that Israel does have the right to violate another country’s sovereignty, like Syria, to defend itself against weapons that might be --

MR. EARNEST:  I appreciate the opportunity to clarify.  You're asking about reports from overnight that I'm just not in a position to comment on.  I can say what the President said last night as a general matter that the Israelis are justifiably concerned about the threat posed by Hezbollah obtaining advanced weapon systems including some long-range missiles.

But in terms of how that relates to specific reports overnight about military action, I'm not in a position to comment on that.  If you do have questions about reports of Israeli action, I'd refer you to the Israelis to talk about that.

Q    Following up on his question, you talked about the constant contacts that the administration has with Israel.  How comfortable is the administration with the contact just in the past three or four days, the past week?

MR. EARNEST:  I'm not in a position to evaluate those communications just because I don't want to talk about them publicly.  But I will just assure you as a principle that the way this administration has operated has been to closely lash up our posture and our intelligence and other security arrangements closely with the Israelis.

Q    So that's in general, but not in specific to the past week?

MR. EARNEST:  That's correct.  I'm just not going to get into the details of those conversations, other than to assure you that our posture has been that we're going to closely coordinate with the Israelis on a range of issues.  And that is continuing.

Q    What does the President plan this week to try to get the immigration bill moving?

MR. EARNEST:  Well, you heard over the last few days the President has talked quite a bit about the bipartisan effort to try to pass comprehensive immigration reform in the Congress.  The President is pleased with the efforts that are underway, that they are making progress, that there have been -- there is an emerging bipartisan agreement.  The President has acknowledged that the agreement that is moving through the Senate right now doesn’t reflect every single thing that he believes should be included in the legislation, but he does believe that the compromise does fulfill the principles that he’s laid out.

The President has put out four clear principles about ensuring that we have the resources necessary to secure the border; about ensuring that employers are held accountable for taking advantage of the broken immigration system.  The President wants to try to streamline and improve and modernize the legal immigration system.  And he wants to make sure that there’s a clear path to citizenship for undocumented Americans [sic] who are already here. 

The compromise fulfills those four principles.  And I think the President is going to continue to have conversations with members of Congress and will continue to talk publicly about why he believes this compromise is important, why it should move through the Senate, and why the President hopes it will land on his desk in the months ahead.

Q    Senator Rubio is taking a lot of flack from the right for his role in trying to put together a bipartisan compromise.  Has the President spoken with him since that one meeting with a number of senators or does he have any plans to?

MR. EARNEST:  I don’t know of any future plans to, and I’m not in a position read out any calls they may have had recently.

Q    -- yesterday the incoming president said that President Obama’s push for gun control is based on revenge.  What is your response to that?  And then also, with senators starting to get heat in their home districts, is the administration going to try to reach out to some people who they think might be swayable?

MR. EARNEST:  I have to admit I didn’t see any of the comments at the NRA convention so I wouldn’t comment on them at this point.  What we have seen is we have seen a response at the grassroots level from American citizens who are concerned about the outcome of the initial effort to try to close loopholes in the background checks system.  The President has indicated -- and he indicated in his remarks at the Rose Garden a few weeks ago -- that this will continue to be a policy priority of his; that there is no reason that we shouldn’t be able to continue to work in bipartisan fashion to make progress on a range of common-sense measures that would reduce gun violence in communities all across the country. 

The background check proposal was a bipartisan proposal -- it was put together by a conservative Democrat and a conservative Republican.  So there’s no reason that we shouldn’t be able to see some progress on this in the Congress.  And the President is going to stay at it.  You heard the Vice President talk about it a little bit last week as well.  This is going to continue to be a priority of ours. 

The way that we’re going to eventually be successful on this -- this actually goes to some of the remarks that the President will make in his commencement address today -- that we’re going to need to see the American people get engaged in this debate.  And there’s plenty of polling data to indicate that there’s strong public support for this -- overwhelming public support for this, actually.  But what we need to see is we need to see Americans get engaged in their democracy and make their voices and opinions heard to members of Congress, and to make it clear that there will be consequences for the way that members of Congress vote on these common-sense measures. 

The President has been very clear about his support for and belief in the Second Amendment of the Constitution.  The President doesn’t have any desire to undermine that fundamental constitutional right for law-abiding Americans.  But he doesn’t believe that that should prevent us from taking common-sense steps to close loopholes in the background checks system.  And I think the vast majority of the American people support that.  And we’re going to make progress on that as the American people make their voices heard on this issue.

Q    Speaking of those consequences, a number of senators who voted against the measure -- Senators Ayotte and Flake, for example, have taken a beating in their poll numbers since that vote.  Does the White House attribute some of their declines to the fact that they voted against this measure that you say the Americans overwhelmingly support?

MR. EARNEST:  I think some of those senators themselves have acknowledged that their poll numbers have suffered as a result of their votes.  So they’re much more sophisticated consumers of polling information than I am.  But I know that Senator Flake, for example, talked about the impact that that had on his standing in the state of Arizona with voters in Arizona, including with gun owners in Arizona.  So I’ll leave it to Senator Flake and others to assess their own poll numbers and the consequences of their vote on common-sense background check legislation.

Anybody else?  Okay, enjoy your breakfast, guys.

END  
10:44 A.M. EDT

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Remarks of President Barack Obama – As Prepared for Delivery

Commencement Address at The Ohio State University
Columbus, Ohio
May 5, 2013

Hello, Buckeyes!

Thank you Dr. Gee, the Board of Trustees, Congresswoman Beatty, Mayor Coleman, and all of you who make up The Ohio State University for allowing me the honor of joining you today.  Congratulations, Class of 2013!  And congratulations to all the parents, family, friends and faculty here in the Horseshoe – this is your day as well.  Just be careful with the turf.  I know Coach Meyer has big plans for fall.

Thank you, Dr. Gee, for that eloquent introduction, although I will not be singing today.  And yes, it is true that I did speak at that certain university up north a few years ago.  But, to be fair, you did let President Ford speak here once – and he played football for Michigan!

In my defense, this is my fifth visit to campus in the past year or so.  One time, I stopped at Sloopy’s to grab some lunch.  Many of you were still eating breakfast.  At 11:30.  On a Tuesday.  So I’ll offer my first piece of advice early: enjoy it while you still can.  Soon, you won’t get to do that.  And once you have kids, it gets even earlier.

Class of 2013, your path to this moment has wound you through years of breathtaking change.  You were born as freedom forced its way through a wall in Berlin, and tore down an Iron Curtain across Europe.  You were educated in an era of instant information that put the world’s accumulated knowledge at your fingertips.  And you came of age as terror touched our shores; an historic recession spread across the nation; and a new generation signed up to go to war. 

You have been tested and tempered by events that your parents and I never imagined we’d see when we sat where you sit.  And yet, despite all this, or more likely because of it, yours has become a generation possessed with that most American of ideas – that people who love their country can change it.  For all the turmoil; for all the times you have been let down, or frustrated at the hand you’ve been dealt; what I have seen from your generation are perennial and quintessentially American values.  Altruism.  Empathy.  Tolerance.  Community.  And a deep sense of service that makes me optimistic for our future.

Consider that today, 50 ROTC cadets in your graduating class will become commissioned officers in the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines.  130 of your fellow graduates have already served – some in combat, some on multiple deployments.  Of the 98 veterans earning bachelor’s degrees today, 20 are graduating with honors.  And at least one kept serving his fellow veterans when he came home by starting up a campus organization called Vets4Vets.  As your Commander-in-Chief, I could not be prouder of all of you. 

Consider, too, that graduates of this university serve their country through the Peace Corps, and educate our children through established programs like Teach for America and startups like Blue Engine, often earning little pay for making the biggest impact.  Some of you have already launched startup companies of your own.  And I suspect that those of you who pursue more education, or climb the corporate ladder, or enter the arts or sciences or journalism, will still choose a cause you care about in your life and fight like heck to make it happen. 

There is a word for this.  It’s citizenship.  We don’t always talk about this idea much these days, let alone celebrate it.  Sometimes, we see it as a virtue from another time – one that’s slipping from a society that celebrates individual ambition; a society awash in instant technology that empowers us to leverage our skills and talents like never before, but just as easily allows us to retreat from the world.  And the result is that we sometimes forget the larger bonds we share, as one American family.

But it’s out there, all the time, every day – especially when we need it most.  Just look at the past year.  When a hurricane struck our mightiest city, and a factory exploded in small-town Texas.  When bombs went off in Boston, and when a malevolent spree of gunfire visited a movie theater, a temple, an Ohio high school, a first-grade classroom in Connecticut.  In the aftermath of darkest tragedy, we have seen the American spirit at its brightest.  We’ve seen the petty divisions of color, class, and creed replaced by a united urge to help.  We’ve seen courage and compassion, a sense of civic duty, and a recognition that we are not a collection of strangers; we are bound to one another by a set of ideals, and laws, and commitments, and a deep devotion to this country we love. 

That’s what citizenship is.  It’s the idea at the heart of our founding – that as Americans, we are blessed with God-given and inalienable rights, but with those rights come responsibilities – to ourselves, to one another, and to future generations. 

But if we’re being honest, as you’ve studied and worked and served to become good citizens, the institutions that give structure to our society have, at times, betrayed your trust.  In the run-up to the financial crisis, too many on Wall Street forgot that their obligations don’t end with their shareholders.  In entertainment and in the media, ratings and shock value often trumped news and storytelling.  And in Washington – well, this is a joyous occasion, so let me put this charitably: I think it’s fair to say our democracy isn’t working as well as we know it can.  It could do better.  And those of us fortunate enough to serve in these institutions owe it to you to do better, every single day.

I’ve been thinking a lot lately about how we might keep this idea alive at a national level – not just on Election Day, or in times of tragedy, but on all the days in between.  Of course, I spend most of my time these days in Washington, a place that sorely needs it.  But I think of what your generation’s traits – compassion and energy, a sense of selflessness and a boundless digital fluency – might mean for a democracy that must adapt more quickly to keep up with the speed of technological, demographic, and wrenching economic change.

I think about how we might perpetuate this notion of citizenship in a way that another politician from my home state, Adlai Stevenson, once described patriotism – not as “short, frenzied outbursts of emotion, but the tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime.”

I don’t pretend to have all the answers.  And I’m not going to offer some grand theory – not when it’s a beautiful day and you’ve got some celebrating to do.  I’m not going to get partisan, either, because that’s not what citizenship is about.  In fact, I am asking the same thing of you that President Bush did when he spoke at this commencement in 2002:  “America needs more than taxpayers, spectators, and occasional voters,” he said.  “America needs full-time citizens.”

And as graduates from a university whose motto is “Education for Citizenship,” that’s what your country expects of you.  So briefly, I will ask you for two things: to participate, and to persevere.

After all, your democracy does not function without your active participation.  At a bare minimum, that means voting, eagerly and often.  It means knowing who’s been elected to make decisions on your behalf, what they believe in, and whether or not they deliver.  If they don’t represent you the way you want, or conduct themselves the way you expect – if they put special interests above your own – you’ve got to let them know that’s not okay.  And if they let you down, there’s a built-in day in November where you can really let them know that’s not okay.

You don’t have to run for office yourself.  But I hope many of you do, at all levels, because our democracy needs you.  I promise you, it’ll give you a tough skin.  I know a little bit about this.  Like President Wilson once said: “if you want to make enemies, try to change something.”

And that’s precisely what the founders left us: the power to adapt to changing times.  They left us the keys to a system of self-government – the tool to do big and important things together that we could not possibly do alone.  To stretch railroads and electricity and a highway system across a sprawling continent.  To educate our people with a system of public schools and land grant colleges, including Ohio State.  To care for the sick and the vulnerable, and provide a basic level of protection from falling into abject poverty in the wealthiest nation on Earth.  To conquer fascism and disease; to visit the Moon and Mars; to gradually secure our God-given rights for all our citizens, regardless of who they are, what they look like, or who they love. 

We, the people, chose to do these things together.  Because we know this country cannot accomplish great things if we pursue nothing greater than our own individual ambition. 

Still, you’ll hear voices that incessantly warn of government as nothing more than some separate, sinister entity that’s the root of all our problems, even as they do their best to gum up the works; or that tyranny always lurks just around the corner.  You should reject these voices.  Because what they suggest is that our brave, creative, unique experiment in self-rule is just a sham with which we can’t be trusted.

We have never been a people who place all our faith in government to solve our problems, nor do we want it to.  But we don’t think the government is the source of all our problems, either.  Because we understand that this democracy is ours.  As citizens, we understand that America is not about what can be done for us.  It’s about what can be done by us, together, through the hard and frustrating but absolutely necessary work of self-government. 

The founders trusted us with this awesome authority.  We should trust ourselves with it, too.  Because when we don’t, when we turn away and get discouraged and abdicate that authority, we grant our silent consent to someone who’ll gladly claim it.  That’s how we end up with lobbyists who set the agenda; policies detached from what middle-class families face every day; the well-connected who publicly demand that Washington stay out of their business – then whisper in its ear for special treatment that you don’t get.  That’s how a small minority of lawmakers get cover to defeat something the vast majority of their constituents want.  That’s how our political system gets consumed by small things when we are a people called to do great things – rebuild a middle class, reverse the rise of inequality, repair a deteriorating climate that threatens everything we plan to leave for our kids and grandkids.

Only you can ultimately break that cycle.  Only you can make sure the democracy you inherit is as good as we know it can be.  But it requires your dedicated, informed, and engaged citizenship.  This citizenship is a harder, higher road to take.  But it leads to a better place.  It is how we built this country – together.  It is the question President Kennedy posed to the nation at his inauguration; the dream that Dr. King invoked.  It does not promise easy success or immediate progress.  But it has led to success, and it has led to progress. 

That brings me to the second thing I ask of you – I ask you to persevere.

Whether you start a business or run for office or devote yourself to alleviating poverty or hunger, remember that nothing worth doing happens overnight.  A British inventor named Dyson went through more than 5,000 prototypes before getting that first really fancy vacuum cleaner just right.  We remember Michael Jordan’s six championships, not his nearly 15,000 missed shots. As for me, I lost my first race for Congress, and look at me now – I’m an honorary graduate of The Ohio State University!

The point is, in your life, you will fail.  You will stumble, and you will fall.  But that will make you better.  You’ll get it right the next time.  And that’s not only true for your personal pursuits, but for the broader causes you believe in as well.  But don’t give up.  Don’t lose heart, or grow cynical.  The cynics may be the loudest voices – but they accomplish the least.  It’s the silent disruptors – those who do the long, hard, committed work of change – that gradually push this country in the right direction, and make the most lasting difference.

Still, whenever you feel that creeping cynicism; whenever you hear those voices say you can’t make that difference; whenever somebody tells you to set your sights lower – the trajectory of America should give you hope.  What young generations have done before you should give you hope.  It was young folks like you who marched and mobilized and stood up and sat-in to secure women’s rights, and voting rights, and workers’ rights, and gay rights, often against incredible odds, often over the course of years, sometimes over the tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime.  Even if their rights were already secured, they fought to secure those rights and opportunities for others.  What they did should give you hope. 

And where we’re going should give you hope.  Because while things are still hard for a lot of people, you have every reason to believe that your future is bright.  You are graduating into an economy and a job market that are steadily healing.  The once-dying American auto industry is on pace for its strongest performance in 20 years – something that means everything to many communities in Ohio and across the Midwest.  Huge strides in domestic energy, driven in part by research at universities like this one, have us on track to secure our own energy future.  And incredible advances in information and technology spurred largely by the risk-takers of your generation have the potential to change the way we do almost everything.

Still, if there is one certainty about the decade ahead, it’s that things will be uncertain.  Change will be a constant, just as it has been throughout our history.  And we still face many important challenges.  Some will require technological breakthroughs or new policy insights.  But more than anything, what we will need is political will, to harness the ingenuity of your generation, and encourage and inspire the hard work of dedicated citizens.

To repair the middle class; to give more families a fair shake; to reject a country in which only a lucky few prosper because it’s antithetical to our ideals and our democracy – that takes the dogged determination of citizens.

To educate more children at a younger age; to reform our high schools for a new time; to give more young people the chance to earn the kind of education you did at Ohio State and make it more affordable so they don’t leave with a mountain of debt – that takes the care and concern of citizens.

To build better roads and airports and faster internet; to advance the kind of basic research and technology that has always kept America ahead of everyone else – that takes the grit and fortitude of citizens.

To confront the threat of climate change before it’s too late – that requires the idealism and initiative of citizens.

To protect more of our kids from the horrors of gun violence – that requires the unwavering passion and untiring resolve of citizens.

Fifty years ago, President Kennedy told the class of 1963 that “our problems are man-made – therefore, they can be solved by man.  And man can be as big as he wants.” 

We are blessed to live in the greatest nation on Earth.  But we can always be greater.  We can always aspire to something more.  That doesn’t depend on who you elect to office.  It depends on you, as citizens, how big you want to be, and how badly you want it.

Look at all America has accomplished.  Look at how big we’ve been.

I dare you to do better.  I dare you to be better.

From what I have seen of your generation, I have no doubt you will.  I wish you courage, and compassion, and all the strength you need for that tranquil and steady dedication of a lifetime. 

Thank you, God bless you, and God bless the United States of America.

President Obama Speaks at Forum on Sustainable Economic Development

May 04, 2013 | 52:46 | Public Domain

President Obama Speaks with business leaders at a Forum on Sustainable Economic Development in San Jose, Costa Rica.

Download mp4 (1997MB) | mp3 (127MB)

Read the Transcript

Remarks by President Obama at Meeting with Business Leaders

10:58 A.M. CST

     PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, thank you so much, Mr. Condo.  And once again, I want to thank President Chinchilla and all the people of Costa Rica for their incredible hospitality.  I've already been scouting out where I'm going to stay when I come back here for vacation.  (Laughter.)  But, unfortunately, I'm going to have to leave after this forum.

     But Arturo and I were discussing backstage the fact that INCAE, which has such a wonderful reputation throughout the region -- I know we have two former alumni who now are Presidents of Panama and Guatemala, respectively -- that the origination of this idea was when President Kennedy visited 50 years ago and I think recognized at that time the enormous potential for the private sector as a critical ingredient in progress and development for the hemisphere as a whole; that when you combine good government with a thriving free market, then that was an extraordinary recipe for opportunity for all people.

     And for me to be able to visit 50 years later and to see how much progress has been made both in the region and in the ties between the United States and Central America I think indicates that President Kennedy’s vision was sound, and it also speaks to I think the importance of us continuing to build these kinds of networks and relationships for the future.

     I've been interviewed several times during the course of my travels both in Mexico and Central America, and I've emphasized that although I understand why there’s been a great focus over the last several years on security issues -- security is important.  It’s very hard to create a strong economy when people are personally feeling insecure.  There’s been a lot of emphasis on immigration, and I understand why that is.  Obviously it’s of great importance to this region and to the United States.  We shouldn’t lose sight of the critical importance of trade and commerce and business to the prospects both for Costa Rica, the United States, and the entire hemisphere.

     The United States considers our trading relationships with CAFTA countries, with Mexico, to be of enormous importance.  When you look at the scale of business that's being done currently, it’s creating jobs in the United States, it’s creating jobs here. And what we want to do is to find ways that we can continue to enhance that relationship, how we can get ideas from this region and find ways in which we can improve and foster small business development, medium-sized business development, make this entire region more competitive. 

Because, as I said to the leaders of SICA yesterday, we now live in a very competitive 21st century world and if we do not have effective integration in our hemisphere, if we don't have the best education systems, the best regulatory systems, if we don't coordinate our activities, then we're going to fall behind other regions of the world.  And given the talents that I've seen on display and that are evident here, I'm confident that we can compete as long as we're cooperating effectively. 

     So, again, I want to thank President Chinchilla for the great hospitality.  I want to congratulate INCAE for its wonderful history.  And I look forward to taking a few questions and maybe I'll hear some ideas in this meeting.

     MR. CONDO:  Absolutely.  Thanks a lot for your words. 

                             * * * *      

     Q    (Inaudible.) 

     PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, there’s no doubt that we’ve made progress.  More progress needs to be made in improving border security and facilitating speed and efficiency when it comes to trade and commerce.

And those two things go hand in hand.  Both in the United States and on the other side of the border in Mexico, as well as our northern border with Canada, a lot of the press focus is on security and immigration.  But one of the arguments that we’ve made in pursuit of comprehensive immigration reform is that you can't separate out the dangers or challenges or concerns of a border from the enormous opportunities that a well-managed, well-regulated border represents.

And so my administration’s focus has been, number one, let’s make sure that we’ve got a sound system of immigration, customs and a regulatory environment, in cooperation with Canada and Mexico, that as much as possible eases the flow of goods and people and services that are legitimate.

So, for example, in the North America Leadership Summit that I have with the Mexican President and the Canadian President, a lot of our work centers around how can we continue to find ways to synchronize existing regulations so that we can speed up the movement of goods and services.  Are there ways in which there are regular, frequent trading practices that are going on between the countries where we essentially are able to put them on a fast lane, as opposed to the more typical travel for tourists or sporadic visitors?  And so that regulatory coordination I think is number one. 

     Number two is infrastructure.  The fact of the matter is, is that we have massive borders both to the south and to the north, and in order for us to make sure that we’re facilitating trade and commerce, we’ve got to have the best infrastructure, the best portals through which people can go in a efficient, effective and systematic way that still allows for us to preserve our security and screen out those problematic elements that might cross our borders.

     And one of the things that I’ve been talking to President Piña Nieto about on our southern border is are there ways that we can do more joint infrastructure investment at a time when all countries -- not just the United States and Mexico, but I’m sure Costa Rica and Guatemala and Panama -- we’re always trying to find money somewhere.  And when it comes to the border, they’re shared.  Are there ways in which we can share some of the costs for continual infrastructure upgrades? 

     But the bottom line is it’s both the hardware, the infrastructure, but also the software, the regulation that's going to make sure that you’ve got an effective border system. 

     Comprehensive immigration reform -- that I’m hopeful we can pass this year, after 30 years -- can make an enormous difference in improving what is already a system that's better than it was.

     But I want to echo what Arturo said about the Central American countries -- and this is not unique, by the way, to Central America.  You see this in other parts of the world like in Africa, for example.  Sometimes it’s easier to transport goods from parts of Central America to the United States than it is from one Central American country to another.  The same is true in parts of Africa where it’s easier to ship something to Europe than it is to the country right next door. 

     And to think about working with the Inter-American Development Bank, with the United States, with other partners, how do we build the kind of connectivity and emphasize internal integration and trade and markets -- that's going to strengthen you.  That will put you in a more effective position to compete in world markets, and it will allow you, then, to interface with Mexico and the United States and Colombia, and other parts of the hemisphere -- because what I said to the SICA leaders yesterday was the more integrated we are, the more effective we’re going to compete internationally. 

     But that's going to require some investment.  I just want to emphasize it’s not just building the road or the bridge or the port.  It’s also having the regulatory structures that make those work.

     Q    Good morning.  I am a Central American from Costa Rica and I am also an MBA student from INCAE.  My question is in relation with early childhood support.  There is strong consensus in Central America that has been validated by the IDD and INCAE that early childhood support is one of the best investments our countries can make.  Yet we are still struggling, trying to provide primary and secondary education coverage to the entire population, and even this is pushing the boundaries of our budgets.  So my question is how can -- or how should countries invest in this without sacrificing gains in other areas?  Thank you.

     PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, I’ll just say very briefly that all the science shows that effective, high-quality early childhood education pays more dividends than almost anything else you can do, educationally.  Because if children get a good start, if they're read to, and their vocabulary is expanding, and they’re taught their numbers and their colors and all the basic building blocks, then they're much more likely to succeed.  And that's true in the United States; that's true here in Central America. 

So the way we think about early childhood education is not just as an add-on to our overall education policy.  What we’re trying to argue in my administration is this is part of our entire education strategy.  It starts when the child is born,  and increasingly, in this knowledge-based economy, it’s going to continue even after people have graduated from college, they’re going to have to continue learning. 

     You’re right that paying for it is difficult and quality control is difficult.  Good-quality early childhood education is not just baby-sitting.  It’s having trained professionals who know how to stimulate very young children to give them the preparation that they need, which means setting up training programs and making sure they’re adequately paid.

     And in terms of financing, in my State of the Union -- because the United States, by the way, we don't have the kind of early childhood education system that I think we should have.  And when you compare what we do to some of the more advanced countries in the OECD, we're not where I want us to be.  So what I did in the State of the Union was propose that we impose an additional federal tax on cigarettes in order to pay for an expansion for high-quality, universal early childhood education. You get the real benefit of reducing smoking, which saves on our health care costs, at the same time as we're able to improve early childhood education. 

     Now, whether we're going to be able to get that passed or not, I don't know.  It’s always a struggle to get new revenue for worthy endeavors, but there’s no bigger bang for the buck that you can get than making this investment in early childhood education.  So I'm going to keep on arguing for it forcefully.

                           * * * *       

Q    Central America has significant renewable energy resources.  Our economies are vast, but the volatility of oil energy prices, because our renewables take longer to put online, also delays and local oppositions are taking us in a state that we're using more fossil fuel -- taking us farther from our original goal of a more sustainable energy mix. 

And on top of that we have earthquakes and frequent severe weather that makes our electrical system vulnerable.  Saying that, how can we accelerate investment in more sustainable energy?  And what are the opportunities and possible role of the U.S. and U.S. companies to work with Central America and to advance in a more sustainable energy mix that the region needs, and to reduce the volatility of our electrical system?  Thank you.

     PRESIDENT OBAMA:  I have to say that all of the SICA leaders that I met with yesterday emphasized this issue of energy.  President Pérez, President Martinelli, and President Chinchilla all focused on the fact that electricity costs here in Central America may cost three times as much as they do in Washington, D.C., and that's a huge structural disadvantage for businesses and families in the region.  So this is something you're going to have to fix. 

Now, the good news is that you’ve already made enormous progress in renewable energies in ways that, in fact, are well in advance of what other parts of the world are doing.  The fact that Costa Rica is already getting 90 percent of your energy from renewable sources is a great achievement, and it means that you’ve got technology and expertise and a tradition of renewable energy in the region that you need to build on.

     And what the United States can do, I think the most helpful thing we can do is work with you -- because we have a common goal of creating more renewable energy sources -- let’s collaborate on research, technology.  Let’s network companies that are advancing new renewable energy strategies and see if we can have more joint ventures and projects.  Because it’s my view that if any of us find good answers to renewable energy, that will spread like wildfire and everybody will ultimately benefit.  It almost doesn’t matter where the innovations occur because they’ll be readily transferable around the world.

     What I also understand is, is that we're not going to immediately be able to transition off of traditional sources of energy -- fossil fuels like oil and gas -- and even Costa Rica, it’s getting a lot of renewable energy, but it’s still got to make up that difference, and that's going to be a transition for all countries over the next 20, 30 years. 

And it’s true that because of the extraordinary advances in technology that we've made in the United States, we are likely to be a net natural gas exporter as soon as 2020.  And so one of the things that I've discussed with your Presidents is how can we potentially use that as a bridging mechanism.  I've got to make a decision -- an executive decision broadly about whether or not we export liquefied natural gas at all.  But I can assure you that once I make that decision, then factoring in how we can use that to facilitate lower costs in the hemisphere and in Central America will be on my agenda.

The last point, which Arturo mentioned but I can't emphasize enough, whether you're talking about traditional energy sources, renewable energy, setting up structures and regulatory regimes for creating economies of scale and efficiencies are critical.

     I was mentioning that in California, the utilities, when they produce energy during non-peak hours, they ship it across the border down to Mexico.  When they have peak hours, they bring that energy back to California.  And because of not only the technology but also the laws that are in place, that saves consumers money on both sides of the border. 

And given the small size of many Central American countries, it’s critical to create a regional market.  And that's not just transmission lines.  It’s also having the rules in place that allow the free flow of energy back and forth.

     People get nervous about that because they're worried, well, Panama is going to steal my electricity, and then Costa Rica, I don't know, maybe they're going to poach some of our power.  But the truth of the matter is, is that everybody stands to benefit.

And we’ll work with the Inter-American Development Bank -- we put forward I think it was last year, maybe it was the year before, when we initiated Connect 2022 -- and so our goal is to use whatever competing power we have to network with the private sector, as well as the public sector to find ways to enhance that integration.  If you can solve this problem, it will free up resources for early childhood education, it will put money in the pockets of consumers, and the economic benefits will be extraordinary. 

So we look forward to partnering with you on that issue.

                         * * * *

     Q    You mentioned, President Obama, that it’s hard for everyone to gather the fiscal resources to invest in these integrated, very valuable -- socially valuable programs.  How do you go about, in your experience, creating such social demand or social support for missions like that that require greater resources and the need for greater resources?

     PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, first of all, at least in the United States, and I'm almost certain -- I haven't looked at the polling, but I'm sure it’s true in Central America -- selling people on the importance of education is not difficult.  People understand, even those who don't have an education understand, that in this economy, if we don't have a highly skilled, highly trained workforce, then we’ll lose.  And I think every parent has aspirations for their children to do even better than they did.  And the only way that's going to happen is, is if they’re getting an excellent education.

     So I think generally, the issue is not going to be, will there be social demand.  I think, number one, it’s making sure that education reforms are in place so that we are using the money that we have as effectively as possible.

     In the United States, what we found is, is that sometimes money in schools are not well spent.  And our schools -- we've had public schools for a very long time, but many of them were designed back in the 1800s in a largely agricultural society; now the needs are different and we've got to adapt.  We also have new tools, like the use of technology and distance learning that can reduce costs and improve outcomes.

     We have to spend a lot of time focusing on teacher quality and training teachers so that they’re up to speed on the best practices to improve learning.

     But I think it is actually easy to get public support around education.  What’s harder is to, A, make sure that the money is well spent; and B, recognize that, as is true for businesses, it’s also true for governments, you have to prioritize, and you have to decide, all right, if we're going to spend more money on early education, then we're going to have to either increase revenue through taxation, or we're going to have to stop doing some other things that are less important.  And that's part of what democracy is about, is having that debate.

     But one last point I want to make about education.  A lot of studies have shown that the single best indicator of a country’s development and advancement is how does it treat its girls.  If you are not educating half the population, if you're not using all the opportunities -- or providing opportunities for all the girls in your country, you will fall behind.  And it’s been said before, the advantage of when you're giving a good education to girls is you're also going to be educating the children of the moms. 

And so making sure that social equity and gender equity is built into our education agenda -- especially around things like math and science and engineering, where traditionally a lot of times young girls are discouraged because it’s viewed somehow as not their subjects -- that's something that we're spending a lot of time on.  And we’d be happy to collaborate with SICA and other organizations to find ways that we can make sure that we're encouraging young women are getting the exact same opportunities as young men are getting.  (Applause.)

                          * * * *

     PRESIDENT OBAMA:  Well, again, I just want to thank this wonderful institution and the people of Costa Rica, as well as President Chinchilla, for giving me this wonderful opportunity to interact with outstanding business leaders and civil society leaders.

     The main message that I have is that the United States recognizes our fates are tied up with your success.  We want to be a partner.  I’ve said this before and I will repeat, we don't think there are senior partners or junior partners in that partnership.  I think it’s a partnership based on equality and mutual respect and mutual interest.  If you are doing well, we will do better.  And if we’re doing well, we think your situation improves. 

And so, through all the various forums that we have, let’s continue to build.  And let’s recognize that in this global economy that we now live in that for us to be successful we’re going to have to further integrate, and we’re going to have to use not just the powers of governments -- government-to-government relations; it’s going to be people to people, business to business.  It’s going to be networks.  It’s going to be private sector, public sector, non-for-profits all working together around common goals. 

     And I think this forum is an extraordinary opportunity to build on the talents of a lot of people from a lot of sectors around the region.  We look forward to working with you.  We look forward to partnering with you.  And I have to say, this visit has made me extraordinarily optimistic about not just the future of the United States and the future of Central America, but the entire hemisphere. 

So thank you very much.  (Applause.

                       END                11:50 A.M. CST

Close Transcript

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

Statement by the President on the Occasion of Orthodox Easter

This weekend, Michelle and I extend our best wishes to members of the Orthodox Christian community here in America and around the world as they observe Holy Friday and the Feast of the Resurrection.  

For millions of Orthodox Christians, this is a joyful time.  But it’s also a reminder of the sacrifice Christ made so that we might have eternal life.  His decision to choose love in the face of hate; hope in the face of despair is an example we should always strive to follow.  But it’s especially important to remember this year, as members of the Orthodox community have been confronted with persecution and violence, particularly in the Middle East and North Africa. For centuries, the region and the world has been enriched by the contributions of Orthodox communities in countries like Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, and Iraq. As a nation, we reaffirm our commitment to protecting universal human rights including the freedom of religion.  And in this season of hope and restoration, we celebrate the transformational power of sacrificial love. 

President Obama’s Visit to Costa Rica

This week, President Obama traveled to Mexico and Costa Rica to reinforce the deep cultural, familial, and economic ties that so many Americans share with Mexico and Central America.

President Barack Obama arrives in Costa Rica

President Barack Obama arrives aboard Air Force One at Juan Santamaria International Airport, San Jose, Costa Rica. May 3, 2013. (Official White House Photo by Lawrence Jackson)

President Obama arrived in Costa Rica on Friday -- his first visit to the country -- and participated in a bilateral meeting and joint press conference with Costa Rican President Chinchilla’s, as well as a working dinner. During the press conference, the President spoke about the friendship and economic ties between our two countries:

Costa Rica shows the benefits of trade that is free and fair. Over the last few years, under the Central America Free Trade Agreement, our trade with Costa Rica has doubled, creating more jobs for people in both of our countries. Our partnerships are creating more opportunities for small businesses and entrepreneurs, including young people and women. As I told President Chinchilla, the United States will continue to be your partner as Costa Rica modernizes its economy so that you’re attracting more investment and creating even more trade and more jobs.

The White House

Office of the Press Secretary

FACT SHEET: United States Support for Economic Growth and Development in Central America

In his meeting with the Presidents of Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Honduras, Panama, Nicaragua, and Dominican Republic, and the Prime Minister of Belize, President Obama discussed the United States commitment to deepening economic collaboration and expanding prosperity and social inclusion in the region.  The leaders also discussed citizen security cooperation and the importance of building safe communities that contribute to a favorable business and investment climate.  The President emphasized the importance of promoting transparent and, accountable government institutions, and the full respect for human rights.  The President joined a forum on inclusive economic growth in Central America hosted by INCAE Business School and the Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) that was attended by more than 200 private sector and civil society leaders.  The President highlighted the region’s untapped potential and the opportunity to expand prosperity through economic integration, removing barriers to trade, improving access to clean and affordable energy, creating educational opportunities, and investing in early childhood development. 

The United States supports the region’s economic growth and social inclusion efforts through multiple, complementary programs that contribute to: building strong, capable and transparent institutions; facilitating trade and creating favorable business and investment climates; expanding access to reliable, clean, and affordable energy; and investing in human capital so that citizens are prepared to contribute to the development of their communities.

For 2012, the United States committed $437 million to Central America to support nutrition, health, education, agriculture, women’s entrepreneurship, the protection of workers’ rights, the elimination of child labor, construction of transportation infrastructure, and creation of transparent government initiatives. The Overseas Private Investment Corporation (OPIC) and the Export Import Bank (EXIM) committed $330 million in financing and insurance that mobilized $100 million in private sector capital enabling new investments in microfinance, and expanded credit for the use of U.S. goods and services in the development of infrastructure, transport and other needs.  These efforts created new markets abroad that supported jobs at home. Highlights of recent U.S. economic growth and social inclusion efforts are summarized below:

Facilitating Trade and Creating Favorable Business and Investment Climates: 

  • Trade and investment flows have increased significantly since initial implementation of the Dominican Republic - Central America – United States Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA – DR) in 2006.  U.S. exports to the CAFTA-DR countries in 2012 increased over 78 percent to $30.2 billion, while U.S. imports in 2012 from CAFTA-DR countries increased nearly 71 percent to $30.9 billion.  Based on trade figures from the CAFTA-DR partners, trade among them has grown 56 percent between 2005 and 2011, demonstrating the benefits of greater intraregional integration.
  • The U.S. - Panama Trade Promotion Agreement (TPA) entered into force on October 31, 2012.  U.S. exports to Panama increased by over $687 million, almost 23 percent, in the first four month period since entry into force of the TPA, compared to the same prior timeframe.  U.S. imports from Panama rose almost 48 percent or $54 million during the first four months since entry into force of the TPA, over the same prior timeframe. 
  • Under Pathways to Prosperity, where countries share best practices on inclusive economic growth, the Departments of Homeland Security and Commerce provided training to 250 representatives from the public and private sectors in risk management, single window, authorized economic operator programs, and ensuring public and private sectors work together to develop border management solutions.
  • USAID recently launched a new $18.9 million regional trade and food security program for Central America and the Dominican Republic, which will improve trade facilitation and support critical value chains to improve food security and link producers to markets.
  • The U.S. contributed $5 million to the $22 million Crossroads Fund administered by the IDB that provides assistance to develop cross-border infrastructure in Central America. 
  • The Partnership for Growth (PFG) has marked a new approach to joint cooperation between the United States and El Salvador.  PFG seeks to expand broad-based economic growth by reducing crime and insecurity, and improving the investment climate and productivity.

Expanding Access to Reliable Clean, and Affordable Energy:

  • By 2030, the World Bank estimates that Central America will need $25 billion in power sector investment to address increasing demand.  OPIC and EXIM Bank have already supported several hundred million dollars in energy related and other projects in Mesoamerica.  As of 2012, EXIM Bank has provided $187 million in loans to support exports of U.S. built wind turbine generators for the Cerro de Hula Wind Farm in Santa Ana, Honduras.  The Cerro de Hula wind farm is producing six percent of the electrical power in Honduras.
  • The Energy and Climate Partnership of the Americas (ECPA) is providing grants to incentivize clean energy development, including a $1 million biomass waste to energy project in Costa Rica. Also under ECPA, the Departments of State and Energy are supporting the Connecting the Americas 2022 initiative, which promotes greater use of renewable energy and more reliable access to electricity through expanded regional electricity interconnections.
  • USAID has launched a five-year multi-million dollar Regional Clean Energy Initiative for Central America to improve the development of clean energy and to reduce energy consumption through energy efficiency.

Building Strong, Capable and Transparent Institutions: 

  • In 2012, MCC completed its first Compact in El Salvador - a $461 million program that targeted reductions in poverty through strategic investments in agricultural production, rural business development, transportation infrastructure, education, and community level infrastructure.
  • The joint State Department-USAID Domestic Finance for Development initiative has allocated more than $10 million to projects in El Salvador and Honduras to improve public financial management by focusing on domestic revenue mobilization, fiscal transparency and anti-corruption measures.
  • In 2012, the Department of Treasury provided $7.3 million in technical assistance to the region.  33 Treasury Technical Advisors embedded in various ministries are providing expertise in tax administration and financial management.  Treasury is also exploring with Central American finance ministers options to establish a pooled catastrophic risk insurance mechanism to provide fast-disbursing liquidity in the aftermath of natural disasters.
  • Guatemala recently agreed to a landmark labor enforcement plan under a CAFTA-DR settlement agreement that includes a process for developing a contingency mechanism to ensure payments owed to workers are made when an export company closes.  This first such initiative in Guatemala offers an important opportunity to strengthen the social safety net for workers to ease their transition to a new job that could be replicated throughout the region. 

Investing in Human Capital:

  • The Inter-American Foundation invested over $5.5 million in 2012 for human capital and citizen-led initiatives in communities in Central America and the Dominican Republic that included land titling and management, crop diversification, and sustainable agricultural practices.
  • The Department of Agriculture provided more than $76 million in assistance supporting food security, agricultural research and in cooperation with USAID, technical assistance to Central American farmers to help fight the spread of the Coffee Rust disease.
  • In 2012, OPIC provided $150 million in financing and insurance to support lending to microfinance institutions and small and medium enterprises throughout Central America. 
  • The Small Business Network of the Americas and Women's Entrepreneurship in the Americas are leveraging public-private partnerships to energize small and medium business development and increase women’s economic participation.
  • Under 100,000 Strong in the Americas, we are preparing students to participate in the 21st century workforce.  More than 8,000 students from Central America and the Dominican Republic studied at U.S. institutions during the 2011-2012 academic year.